Black Square Analog Beechcraft Bonanza A36 / G36

I noticed that a poor VOR signal does not give the autopilot any issues. The needle can be flying back and forth but AP is as happy as larry. I assume there is no way to model interference for the AP? Bit of a shame because it makes the interference feel sorta superficial.

Unfortunately, there does not appear to be any concept of a Noisy VOR signal ( at long range, low signal-to-noise ratio), so we are left with MSFS having a hard DIGITAL switch on/off between a Full signal & no signal, with the Boolean variable for the VOR being active, based purely on fixed defined Range, (day or night)

This is a shame, as there is also a VOR signal strength variable, that changes quite well with range & altitude, as well as when flying over the top of the VOR, which, 0ne might assume, is being used to control the noisiness of any analogue needle in a 3PD’s plane, but does not appear, from user reports, to be affecting the signal to noise of the signal being fed to the AP, this the AP remains overly stable.

Actually, this may not be as bad as it is seeming, depending on how much damping is present in the real world, and how much is being simulated in the Plane’s AP system.

Tough call to say what is more accurate, or indeed if the current simulation is that far from realistic.

However, what is clearly (and audibly) Missing, is any Noise on the VOR’s Ident signal, as the distance to the VOR increases, to a marginal operation range, and the fact that one should be able to hear a Noisy, when listening to an almost out of range Vor, when its signal to noise ratio is so low, that the electronics deems the signal too low, and thus stops using it.

Also missing in MSFS is any concept of radio audio manual Squelch control.

BTW: For a 3PD to start adding in that audio noise, is not an easy task, especially if it is going t be a function of terrain, and line of sight .

Pilot Edge have however managed to do so, to some extent, with their own Custom MP system, which adds another level of realism & Immersion.

Well done Pilot Edge 
 :+1:

========

If you find the above of interest, you might like to check out this informational link, and see how many answers you know, on it’s multiple choice answer test .

Unfortunately the VOR/ADF needle signal attenuation they’ve added in needs a lot of work. Have you also noticed that the HSI CDI wanders even when you’re in GPS mode? And yeah, the autopilot should be doing a bit of wandering too until you’ve got a solid signal, which may not be as easy to do. That’s on top of the ADF needles not resting at 90 and having no turning errors. But hopefully they can fix all that.

The flight model of the A36 is a whole other thing
 man does it need work.

I read this, and
 :rofl: :rofl:
We can’t win, can we :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

(“The AP is totally unstable!”
 “The AP is too stable!” (runs away screaming))

1 Like

In all fairness, until a few months ago, the AP did go into a permanent unstable mode, if turned on on the ground for any time, and then later turned on in the Air.

Asobo provided a solution to that issue, by correctly introducing a Mode, where the AP effectively “reset” when it was turned off. (PID - Clear the Integral error)

So, now, if this mode is set correctly by the plane Devs, the 


“I turned on my AP in the air ,the plane went into a spin/ dive/ stall , and it crashed the plane”,

should be a thing of the past.

You can now also do a valid AP test when on the ground, and live to fly another day 


2 Likes

Final touches on my small mods to this fantastic mod.If everything goes well it should be available this weekend.

16 Likes

It’s the standard mixture axis. In the Baron as well as in the Bonanza (mixture axis or mixture 1 / mixture 2 axis).

In Spad.next it looks like this:
image

I was referring to the turbo versions G58P, or A36TC. It’s different

For the Turbo version of the Baron it is an LVAR (“BKSQ_MIXTURELEVERPOSITION_1” and “BKSQ_MIXTURELEVERPOSITION_2”) - screenshot from SPAD.NEXT:


For the Bonanza A36TC it’s “BKSQ_MIXTURELEVERPOSITION_1”.

In the in game control settings it is mixture 1 axis and mixture 2 axis (-100 to +100)

2 Likes

What is your Mod ??

He is redoing the cockpit with improved textures and more realistic instrument fonts and labels. I look forward to trying it.

3 Likes

Hi all,

Just to inform that my enhanced Bonanza cockpit is now available @ flightsim.to

A special thanks to NiKoTin3420 and JayDee for their comments and support.

Happy flying and waiting for your comments or suggestions !



Capture d’écran 2023-04-02 061203

14 Likes

Looks amazing – and “Real” – great job 


2 Likes

Didn’t do so much.I just refined details.All the compliments must be adressed to Nick the Black Square developper who has made a tremendous job.I just beautified a little bit his job!

3 Likes

image

Oooops :wink:

2 Likes

Thanks for the feedback.Will post the correction today.:wink:

2 Likes

Update available on flightsim.to (v1.02) with corrected texture :wink:

3 Likes

Just got it, thank you. Can’t wait for the Caravan enhancement one day.

Does anyone know if there is a fix yet or one coming for the terrible texture reflections in the storm window?

yes you can ask JF

3 Likes