Control loss as soon as wheels hit the runway in Beechcraft Baron

Good evening to all,

Apoogies if this is a similar post to others - I have seen similar posts, but most are at least two if not three years old (unless I’ve missed others…)

Concerns the Beechcraft Baron, and the totally erratic response once wheels touch the runway during landing.
I have a pretty flawless approach ( if I say so myself), but the wheels hit the runway and we’re dancing all over the shop.

I have checked bindings, and created a dead zone to the rudder. The ‘co-pilot’ did say that my landing speed should be 84 knots, but that seems very slow…

I’ve tweeked the rudder axis response curve a little, but the control loss is really so severe…

Has there been any sort of resolution to this since it was last posted, and if so, could someone advise…??

Does the live weather pre-set have anything to do with it?

Using the Alpha and Bravo Honeycomb units plus the Thrustmaster pedals.

Thank you in advance!

is this the default or some vendor?

I’ve not had any issues…What controls are you using?

It’s the 2024 default version.

Using the standard rudder axis with the Thrustmaster pedals.

No binding conflicts that I can see….

You might try desensitizing the action of the pedals

Thank you, but I have tried that - created a dead zone and made some small adjustments to the rates - do you have numbers you can recommend?

I tried it all again in a different aircraft - the Cirrus G2 I think - and just as bad. Touched down dead centre, and an immediate lurch to the right, almost as if I’d put full right rudder on.

Hi,
does only the standard Baron show this strange behaviour?
Do you have any assistance options active? They can cause strange things.

Regards, Frank

Hi there - the Cirrus G2 jet does the same.

No assistance options turned on - auto rudder is off.

Tried the jet this morning, and after a reasonably perfect (!) approach, touched down and got a massive lurch to the right, almost as if I’d put full right rudder on.

If I didn’t know that rudder control had been an issue with MFS2024 previously, I’d have said that something was wrong with the pedals. Having said that, in the config screen, the rudder axis appears to be functioning normally - smooth, no jumping and certainly nothing to suggest any behavior that would induce the lurch!!

How about your toe brakes, or even parking brake? What is their state on touchdown. Do you touch down on one wheel only. With some braking action that would pivot your aircraft immediately.

Do you try to “butter” smooth the touchdown? Better have a firm (not hard) touchdown, gives you more control. Also speed might be too high. Aim for Vref when flaring and reduce thrust.

One wheel touchdown I do try to avoid, occasionally (or maybe a bit more) one wheel touches down briefly before the other.

Toe brakes are up on touchdown. However, I may be braking too late after touchdown - I’ve been experimenting over the last hour or so, and a harsher brake after touchdown does improve things a little. At least the abrupt lurch isn’t quite so bad…

I’m working on the speed - I think during MFS2020 my landing speeds were higher than they should have been - my co-pilot when switched on advises a landing speed of 84kts on landing which I don’t think I ever did in 2020…nearer 100kts previously.

I did just roll the aircraft down the runway at ultra slow speed and found that the aircraft does pull to the left - possibly due to engine torque in the Beechcraft or runway camber.

My rudder pedals are four or five years old - maybe time to replace them, but I’d like to be more convinced that it’s either me or the sim before parting with more cash…!!

For the Vision Jet, in a full flaps landing configuration, at a low weight your Vref is in the range of 76 to 81 KIAS. I would rather go towards the lower value as MSFS doesn’t let you stall easily.

Also retract flaps immediately after nose wheel is down on ground to reduce lift. Also helps with control.

Thank you, that’s something to try.

Thank you everyone for your help so far!

Your own numbers give the game away — over the fence at 100 knots when the book says 84. Sixteen knots fast means the wings are still flying when the wheels touch, so there’s hardly any weight on the tyres, and the smallest bit of drift or a one-wheel touchdown turns into exactly the lurch you’re describing. However good it looks, an approach at the wrong speed isn’t a flawless approach.

I fly a 172 in the real world, and what fixed my landings wasn’t anything in the flare — it was refusing to accept the wrong speed on short final, even though the right number feels uncomfortably slow at first. Get it down at the proper speed with all three wheels sharing the load, then keep your feet working until you’re at walking pace. The landing isn’t over at touchdown — that’s the moment the aeroplane most wants to leave the runway.

Thank you again for the replies - shall endeavour to keep trying.

I shall apply similar endeavours to correct my take-off swerving as well.

I have applied some reduction in sensitivity to the rudder after watching a video on rudder set up on you tube…currently set to -0.85 on both curves. Wonder what other folks’ numbers are at?

Cheers to all!

Had a much better overall experience this evening with both take off and landing.

Rudder set to -0.6 as recommended by GlennyPlays (thank you!), and airspeed significantly reduced for landing. Also rotated earlier on take-off to avoid the slipping and sliding rudder-wise experienced before.

I’m interested in teh Navigraph academy - is this a stand alone sim, or an academy linked to MSflight sim? Not heard of it before - I’ll start investigating tomorrow, but a heads-up as to what’s involved woudl be great.

Have to say (slightly off topic) that I’m finding the route planning really good within MFS2024, and so far I have to say that the ATC seems to be better than MFS2020 by some margin…unless I’ve spoken too soon…

Unbelievable transformation with much slower approach.

Not sure I’m crossing the fence at 84kts, but am definitely hitting the runway at nearer 84 in the Cirrus Vision.

Just landed on a runway in S America in virually zero visibitlity on the descent, and no ILS on the approach to lock on to. Hit the runway just fine with no loss of rudder control at all.

I’m definitely going to investigate the Navigraph course at some point. However, the crisis of the last 48hrs has definitely subsided!!!

Thank you again to all who helped out. Solution to my problem solved.

One thing to keep in mind is that energy is the square of velocity. So if you’re coming over the threshold at 100 instead of 84, you’re only about 19% faster, but you’re carrying about 42% more kinetic energy. That extra energy has to go somewhere. It’s very difficult to land an airplane that still wants to fly!

Glad it came right — “much slower approach” is nearly always the whole answer with the Baron. And IslandSimPilot’s numbers are worth pinning: 16 knots over the book speed doesn’t sound like much until you see it’s 42% more energy the runway has to absorb. An aeroplane that still wants to fly will find any excuse to swap ends on you. Enjoy the Baron, it’s a proper machine once you fly it by the book

Two stonking landings today in the Daher TBM 930 - one with an initial APR approach on the localiser, and one completely self-sufficient as there was no ILS.

The joy is back - no more sliding around the runway.

Thanks again to all for the help and contributions. Much appreciated.