MSFS vs P3D V5 - Visual Comparison

This topic was automatically opened after 96 minutes.

My friend, I totally agree with you, P3D V5.1 for real virtual pilot. MSFS is just a game, maybe a simulator at a later time.

1 Like

Perhaps the mods should lock this one for good. The whole P3D for ā€œreal virtual pilotā€ vs MSFS ā€œgameā€ narrative is frankly tired and old.

So let’s close this shall we and let the trolls go back under their bridges.

10 Likes

A pretty unfair comment for a platform like MSFS, calling it just a game… It’s alright we all know that we’ve still got some important bugs and even ā€˜dumbgrades’ then again MSFS rocks over any other similar thing in the market.

4 Likes

MSFS is incredible looking and a massive technical achievement. I’m having tons of fun flying slowly around the globe in the TBM930, I’m waiting on updates and better airliners before I get back into the jets (I’m a former PMDG 737, 777 and Aerosoft A320 FSX simmer). But it’s hands down the future of flight sim. Just needs time to iron everything out and get polished just like P3D, Xplane, FSX etc.

I think you are correct, it did get an earlier release and probably could have been more polished, but screw it I’d rather play what they have now then invest anymore time and money in the old sims, a few more stability and SDK updates and the introduction of some 3rd party airliners and MSFS will be the go to I have no doubts.

When has anything in the flight sim world ever moved fast haha

5 Likes

Thats great meanwhile some of us would rather use our older sims in addition as there are still pretty cool addons being made for them to enjoy and experience.
Just because a new sim is released doesn’t all of a sudden stop progress nor enjoyment of older titles.
Nothing is a waste of money when it brings you joy.

2 Likes

100% Agree, I do not think any money I spent on the older sims was a waste.

Personally I just don’t want to invest any more but definitely if you love it keep at it. When MSFS is stable and has the added features and content that everyone wants I hope most of the flight sim community jumps over. The more people in one place the better for support/3rd party products/updates etc.

Aha and what makes it different? Oh I know how, remove the state of the art weather, remove the scenery streaming feature, remove handcrafted airports, remove, remove and remove and you have to keep it ugly as much as possible. Wait one more thing, change the pricing, instead of 59€, charge 200€ for a professional license. There you have it, a MSFS for professional real hardcore simmers.

1 Like

People still have issues with P3D and X-Plane. Crashes with PMDG/QW etc. They ain’t perfect either. MSFS looks a million times better. I’m not going back and having to re-download everything to make P3D even flyable - people seem to miss this point!

Yes that’s the sad thing. A 15 year old sim is more realistic than next gen.

What a disappointment this game turned out to be.

So true,

I fly airliners, no comparison I love P3d, but with Ga I do love low flying scenery in MSFS. I have 4 hard drives we really have the best of two worlds, the competition will keep flight simulation good for us all. If it ever gets to the point where there’s only one then we will get screwed.

1 Like

Well, that’s P3D for you buddy

MSFS 2020 rocks over anything else when it comes to visuals, it’s the next best thing after our planet itself.

1 Like

Nothing beats MSFS visually…the terrain textures alone.
How is anything prior with jigsaw puzzle terrain flat baked rooftops and objects even comparable at this point?

1 Like

What is the main purpose for a flight sim ? For me is flying.

MSFS 2020 all the way.

1 Like

Knowledge of how ā– ā– ā– ā–  works!

Comparing the performance of a 6 years old sim with tons of addons probably worth hundreds of dollars to a newly released sim…hmmm I would like the to have what ever your having mate. and… real virtual pilots ??? okay… I assume ReAl ViRtUaL PiLots can land real airliners thn… There are real pilots and there are simmers, aka HOBBY. no need to make it complex.

1 Like

What comes visuals and scenery coverage, FS2020 wins. X-Plane and P3D have other advantages, but if you are new one I would not recommend to buy x-Plane or P3D. DCS is good buy even new simmer.

Biggest disadvantage of FS2020 is that there is no helicopters.

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.