New MSFS 2020 - Cessna L-19 Bird Dog to be released today

So this just happened.

Early this morning (see above) that anon. review at msfsaddons posted this when the dev made 1.3 available. The original post showed v1.3

I called him out for having a review of 1.3 when 1.3 was just made available

Post then got edited to this (shows 1.2) I took a screenshot

Since then the dev has pulled back 1.2 and seems to be releasing it later today or soon.

Funny enough, the review got edited to reflect that version change back to v1.1

Come on BBS, really?

7 Likes

Wow… just,

wow

This thread has saved me some money. All I’m gonna say.

4 Likes

Best part is on the second edit he forgot to edit the part in the middle where the ā€œreviewerā€ says:

(Black Box, Hello? V1.3 maybe?)

for the record BBS, you need to edit that also to say V1.2 maybe? or it doesn’t make sense.

ooops!

3 Likes

His friend also makes the standard appearance (cirrus) as if he just happened to come along and see the review and have the same experience.

And then here is the dev confirming parts of my review while pretending to play devil’s advocate.

My only regret is hesitating and feeling bad the night of for maybe making a mistake posting it. I didn’t make a mistake, and it’s only getting more humorous IMO.

He’s clearly setting the thread up for a v1.2 with ā€œfixedā€ upside down switches.

Odds anyone?

2 Likes

I hope MS QA catches this and does not allow it in this state.

4 Likes

What were those odds? The good news is we got an update.

Wish he would stop the shenanigans and just work on the plane.

2 Likes

Looks like a blast to fly, I need to pick this up. need a more ā€˜beat up’ looking livery :wink:

2 Likes

On the bright side, the liveries are nice.

1 Like

Please take this as a positive idea and not a criticism. With all the correspondence going on between you and the developer, perhaps you could offer to be a beta tester on his next project. With his actual ability and your critical eye, maybe you can together come up with something that benefits the entire community.

I know a lot has been said about this developer, and much of it is not nice in nature. But please let us understand that he is one of only very very few people to so far even offer us additional aircraft for this platform. This is something we should encourage, even if some feel the need to give a message that there has been dissatisfaction with past endeavours.

It would be nice to turn this entire situation from a potential lemon experience into actual lemonade.

1 Like

I do not disagree. I realize that there is a lot of pre-thread to read through, and I don’t expect you to do all that, but the offer has been made above, and I tried consistently to try and meet him halfway or offer positives when they applied.

What I got from that was dismissed as a customer and deceit and dishonesty and slander and accusations.

Kind of blown away at this point, but all my prior comments still stand. I’m not unreasonable and have no problem helping, but every time I’ve attempted to reach across the isle I’ve been bit.

3 Likes

For some additional context, I’m a developer by trade and ex-pilot. Not an authority, just a decent combo of both to have in your corner. I’ve also contributed to dozens of open source projects and love to help.

Pre-review I contacted the developer to ask if there was anything in particular they were proud of or that they thought I should mention or review. I also delayed the review on his request to wait for v1.1 update which I did in kind to be as fair as possible.

I feel I’ve gone well beyond in effort compared to how a company (large or small) has in return treated their customer.

4 Likes

This little plane is a hoot to fly and honestly, it’s hard for me to understand the chorus of criticism it has received. It is categorically not even close to perfect, but were Asobo’s planes initially? (A320N, DBM 930, Cessna Citation anyone?) This has become my go-to aircraft because it is simply so much fun to fly. I am no BBS fanboy. But I will say this: alot of people are missing on alot of flying enjoyment because they seem determined to allow the stated experiences of others to take the place of trying it out themselves. If they did, there would be alot fewer complaints about this aircraft.I realize that everyone is entitled to an opinion, but I wanted share mine as based on actual purchase and use, and not things that I have heard from some others. Happy flying all-

2 Likes

Thank you for the additional clarity. I do hope you two can patch up the rapport in some way. But that will take bilateral consensus.

So you’re saying everyone should ignore reviews and just spend their money blindly? That’s never going to happen.

1 Like

Please show me where I said that people should ā€œignore reviewsā€ and ā€œspend their money blindly.ā€
Take all the time you need.

1 Like

No problem. Just a quick copy and paste…

3 Likes

This thread has degraded to a mud-slinging contest. Give it rest.

4 Likes

This is going to sound harsh. Meant as constructive criticism. No way to sugar coat it. After looking at one screenshot of the virtual cockpit (where I spend all of my time simming), it was clear this model is maybe, maybe, FSX default quality. That low-poly mesh. Those textures. 128x128?. When I see that, I assume the rest of the plane is of a similar quality. Please note that I’m not saying the visual quality is bad. I’m saying it would have been standard 15 years ago. Literally.

I don’t think I’d pay $10 for this, or even download it as freeware.

4 Likes

WHY ???

A Simple TYPO Thats Why ! ! ! !

JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEZ What is wrong with you ???

1.1.0 - CURRENT VERSION
1.2.0 - DUE FOR RELEASE TODAY

Now please give it a rest building HUGE Mountains from TINY MOLEHILLS !

1 Like

COULD NOT AGREE MORE !!
Its ridiculous picking up on a simple typo and blowing it out of ALL Proportion

Nothing short of PATHETIC DESPERATION !

I will not be responding in this thread in future as the Clear Agenda (of some) Simply means that Any comment or action, positive or otherwise, is Twisted, Manipulated and Falsely represented .

I look forward to releasing V 1.2.0 ( THATS ONE POINT TWO POINT ZERO !)