I should have explained more what I meant by realism.
I currently fly using a twist joystick (LOGITECH extreame3dpro) (I do not currently have the finances for the whole yolk and pedal set up)
I have a whole bunch of addons that I get on with perfectly fine using this method.
I was more trying to find out if the Carenado version is more user friendly when it comes to using a joystick or weather they both behave in a similar way. This for me is really key at the moment to enjoy the experience
I have heard some people say the SWS version currently is probably best left alone until later if you have a joystick.
Really appreciate this in depth review and right now based on what people are saying I am thinking that the Carenado version is the best place to start, with the view to get SWS later on this year.
For my situation would you agree for this to be the way to go?