I’ve tried full throttle in free flight and I don’t hit the same engine malfunctions (with realism settings). I think this is specific to the career mode and not being able to complete this training missing from LA means you’re not able to get any other extended attack missions. Seems like a bug in the mission.
You can complete it. If you can’t take off just crash into something and it spawns you in the air. Not the best but atleast you can finish the mission to unclock others.
Do you have the same issue if you follow the OP’s steps to reproduce it?
• Same problem. I’ve even tried flying the plane in free flight and trying to keep everything under red line, I still get an engine damage issue. This doesn’t happen to me with any other aircraft.
Provide extra information to complete the original description of the issue:
•
If relevant, provide additional screenshots/video:
•
same for me. engine malfunction until they shut down and I crash even with 70-80% torque. as soon as I filled up my water tanks I cannot take off anymore even with full throttle and full flaps. unmanageable that plane
Ok I finally got it, took me a lot of experimenting, so I want to share my approach here. No luck completing the mission though, CTD on short final
what a joy this simulator is…
Engine malfunction: Under no circumstances allow the engine to overheat - even a short moment will damage it, then it overheats even faster and you are done. Torque in yellow is fine for a short time - just watch the temperature, keeping it there will overheat the engine. NP suffers from a bug - never put the throttle into flight idle - on the ground this will put NP in the lower red range, in flight this will make the NP skyrocket out of scale. I have not tested if this specifically leads to engine malfunction, but I decided to avoid it to be sure.
For scooping: Do not get too slow, touch down very gently, stay around 80 knots and try to avoid bouncing. Increase the throttle as the plane fills up. Input full throttle as the plane fills up completely, lift off gently, retract flaps, put throttle back to green torque range before overheating the engine. Also take wind into account. On the inital mission I got 287 at 11, so I approached the lake from the east of the dam, going into the west arm from there. A bit scary to climb in the narrowing valley at full load, but it works. If anything goes wrong, you can dump the load and scoop again.
Relevant bugs:
- CTD on short final (had this 2 out of 3 times I tried to land on land).
- Never put throttle to flight idle to avoid red NP area
- The stick shaker starts well in the green area, not sure it should be like this.
- Copilot states it is okay to go back to the fire if tanks are not full, but mission does not continue.
Thank you for the bug report.
We have created an internal ticket to see if our team already has this logged, and if not they will attempt to reproduce the issue and create a new bug report. This item is now marked as feedback-logged. If there is an existing bug report or one is created, we will move this thread to bug-logged.
Don’t redline the engine.
Nope. If not 100% full mission will not go on. Tested the last three hours. Dropping water after you have 100% and are still on the water works but stopping the drops works only in 5% of all cases.
Taking of with 100% water and all in the green is not possible even in the starter mission. Bugged as anything else in this game ![]()
The CL-415 isn’t bugged or broken in this way. In fact, it appears to be fairly realistic. It needs to be flown in a realistic way and will punish ‘sim’ flying. The biggest FM issue I’ve seen so far is the drag seems to be too high (at least in level flight).
In game, the 415 can be on/off the water with a full load in ~15 seconds with good technique. It’s also fully capable of taking off with a full load of water and a full load of fuel (ie. max weight). It seems to perform close to real-world spec when flying with real-world technique. Compared to real-life float flying, the 415 while scooping might be the best MSFS has ever done water physics, but this is only true while scooping and with proper technique. All other aspects of aircraft on water are pretty rough.
The biggest issue for sim pilots is the lack of documentation. When all you get to fly a highly specialized plane is “Approach at 90kts” and “Scoop at 60kts”, you’re going to have a bad time. Many sim pilots are learning that more realism comes with more consequences.
What this aircraft really needs is a better training mission, maybe a training mission in the “Activities” that can better run you through a scoop/drop. Float flying has new and interesting ways to kill you when compared to tarmac, and is more of a niche knowledge base. Hopefully this can be developed over time!
Yes the engine malfunction can happen but the mission is doable. Did it on 3rd try. Maybe those will help: dont fly at 100% engine power, scoop to 50% and complete the mission with 5 scoops. Of course you cannot bounce while scooping.
So the CTDs I had in the first flights with the CL-415 at least do not seem to occur any more. However, today I had an engine malfunction without going into the red while scooping (just briefly using the yellow torque range which was fine in previous tries). This was during a scoop where the aircraft started to bounce a bit too hard - is it implemented that rough bouncing leads to an engine malfunction?
Do you have the same issue if you follow the OP’s steps to reproduce it?
• Yes, always. It seems to happen when you try to abruptly climb or when trying to liftoff the lake with the tank full. Aircraft won’t climb at all.
Provide extra information to complete the original description of the issue:
• Very buggy mission, unplayable.
If relevant, provide additional screenshots/video:
•
Do you have the same issue if you follow the OP’s steps to reproduce it?
• Yes and also if I just alt-n to the initial attack - no matter what I set for bleed or anti-ice when I am in the attack (sadly about 3-4 min after pressing alt-n) I am immediately greeted by an engine malfunction.
Provide extra information to complete the original description of the issue:
•
If relevant, provide additional screenshots/video:
•
