Maximum rolling cache size that doesn't have adverse effects?

That’s great but also not really an official communication, and one that’s easy to miss.

If above 128gb consistently causes noticeable issues, there should really be a hint about this directly on the UI.

My point is, we can’t see the actual data inside the cache, and while it’s possible I’ve missed some communication from Microsoft, I don’t recall any that specifically addressed how that data is allocated to a cache, or to a real-time stream.

I would question what’s being cached around airports. There are plenty of reports of “object popping” around hand-crafted airports and PG-rich areas, even when those areas are visited multiple times.

I’ve done tests where I’ve repeated flights over resource-intensive areas, and have seen almost no improvement in that regard. I don’t pretend to know how the LOD curves work in the SDK, or how the cache is used, or even what data it’s intended to handle.

That’s what feeds my curiousity. If you have an inside track to that kind of info, I’d love to read about it.

Obviously I don’t have inside info. All I said was “we know roughly what it does”, because your question made it sound like every single aspect of it is a mystery. I’d like to know more too!

As for the popping in, I’d assume that’s more of an OLOD issue, independent of whether something is cached or not. I see it too all the time, the sim and/or today’s hardware simply can’t handle the amount of objects that it’s supposed to render at once and across long distances imo.

A lot of people overlook the speed of their storage device when buying or building a PC and just look at storage size so I guess theoretically there is a limitation to how large you have the RC depending on the speed of your drive as it may become counterproductive once it has access certain data from a very large data set.

That said most drives these days will be fast enough to allow for a very large cache but what is fast enough to access files outside the game may not necessarily be fat to maintain the nearly instant access required for loading in game assets.

I imagine network and streaming would be more an issue but given you can now download many aspects of the sim the need for rolling cache is probably overstated anyway.

I never use the RC in 2020 and have very smooth performance.

Agreed, but I think it’s less about performance and about the assets that are downloadable. I’d just like it if ground textures and especially PG in areas that I visit often don’t need to reload every single time, so if the cache was big enough to keep a lot of that in there before it gets overwritten.

I’ve had similar thoughts re: drive speed, that probably has some impact.

I don’t know where “above 128gb consistently causes noticeable issues” comes from, but I have had mine set from 256GB to 320GB since release without any issues. There must be more to it than just the size of the rolling cache.

For me, mostly from the extensive thread linked to near the start of this thread.

To wit…

I have mine set to 350 and it’s fine.

Same, I’ve had it at 500gb and it also seemed “fine”. The problem is, as soon as you then get a stutter for whatever reason, you start thinking “I wonder whether I could’ve avoided that by lowering cache” :sweat_smile:

As I mentioned above, I had it at 256GB and lowered it to 128GB and did not see a difference.

Increased my RC yesterday from 32GB to 128GB to address an issue I’ve been having since the PMDG 77W & 77F became available to stream in SU2. Somewhere along the way I had forgot to increase my RC after some sim update, whatever. The streamed T7s flights were picking up short pauses about 10 minutes into climb. This thread prompted me to look a little deeper so I started checking the Task Manager during each pause. Lo and behold the only thing elevated was Network Activity for 24! Duh, it was taking little breaks in my T7 flights to stream in more data! I’m now 50 min into a flight from EWR to IAH and the problem is largely resolved!

There comes a point that it takes longer to search through the massive rolling cache, find or don’t find the data, then load it while perhaps saving and deleting other data that it no longer works well. In the early days of FS24, many of us were using 64-128Gb just to get airliners to work. In SU3 beta on Xbox series X I’m using 32Gb at the recommendation of a few people and it is working really well flying the A20N and the PMDG 777-300ER in and out of 3rd party airports

I believe in a livestream they recommended a minimum of 16Gb but I couldn’t recall if they gave an upper limit but I see people mentioning it on this thread

But with 32GB,you are basically reloading PG cities every time you return to them, assuming you’ve visited some others in between. That’s what I want to avoid if possible. It’s really immersion breaking to see all those cardboard boxes load into actual buildings every time :sweat_smile:

And I have a fast connection, 500mbits down.

Perhaps I need to add that I have PG off due to my 70mb download connection being barely able to handle the basic sim never mind any fancy extras

That’s above the recommended spec though. Should mostly work, according to them at least.

Indeed it is. And I don’t understand how 10mb could possibly work. Definitely not in an airliner anyway

So, after SU3 for msfs2024 we are able to download a lot of the game content. Considering that I have download everything that is available, would I have any benefit by increasing the rolling cache size from its 16gb default? And if yes, considering that I have plenty of free space, is there a specific size that you guys suggest?

Thank you!

It seems there’s is an “official” recommendation of 128gb max. Another user in a thread linked above has done extensive testing and come to a similar conclusion.

But your mileage may vary, much bigger could be fine too, hard to say.

I guess they never measured where the threshold is..

Thank you!