Real time car traffic

on parts of the M25, that would be entirely accurate or even maybe a little on the fast side.

1 Like
  • Honey, where have you been?

  • just shopping with my bff..

  • aah, nope, I followed your car in flight sim. that wasn’t the mall.

:innocent:

4 Likes

what is your understanding of “real-time traffic” ? .. I see cars, and so on..

sound as if we give up flying and turn back to our cars for a highway drive. asking for a live road traffic on FS is much of a “luxury”, whereby we have a dozen of other more important stuff to be fixed so soon.

1 Like

This is funny, I was thinking the same thing just yesterday. Does not seem to unrealistic, as traffic is tracked already like plane are. I believe this SHOULD be in the flight simulator. Yes, it may have nothing to do with flying per say, but when you fly, you look down and see the world. Thus, realistic in a simulator. Do planes sometimes have to land on hiways Yep!

1 Like

I love this idea, it’s “simple” things like this that start to make the world more believable. Agree it’s probably not at the top of the list now but maybe we’ll get lucky somewhere down the line.

The scope of the sim is huge and it’s exciting to see what they’ll do in the next weeks, months, years, decades (eek!).

A similar nice to have would be to increase the scope of fauna from the odd bear here and there to fields of cows, sheep and horses oh yes and people outside of airports :slight_smile:

Am I dreaming or did one of the patches bring in powerlines? I swear I saw one outside of london that was never there before!

1 Like

To be fair to the original post and hopefully respecting the dissenters, X-Plane is able to have Euro traffic versus North America traffic. In the UK the traffic drives on the opposite side. X-Plane also has real marine traffic (maybe not real time, but real scheduled). XP also has train traffic (I don’t think it’s real time, just random). Apparently, road traffic can impact FPS in XP so many turn it off or way down. In MSFS, I think the engine is different than XP and probably much better since I can run MFSF on high settings with my mediocre rig (not so with XP). I think MSFS could afford to introduce real time traffic (road, marine and rail) without too much of a hit on FPS. Here’s hoping they can get through the initial bugs so we can get some of this stuff going.

1 Like

Keep in mind: everything you see from the cockpit is PART of simulation. Even the smallest detail. And computers are almost monthly more and more powerful these days
 I agree they have to fix a lot of thinks but they can add new thinks like Japan, VR, Elephants, birds.. etc in parallel. Don’t block advancement in simulations
 Every detail is important!

There is much bigger picture. These are all baby steps towards something called “Simulation Theory” Google it !

I think live traffic could probably eventually be done, but I don’t think it would add much value. Though I would like to see more accurate traffic, which an algorithm could be based off of real traffic from Bing.

The traffic now is honestly pretty bad, and even though some people are fine, it’s a bit of an immersion killer. For me it’s like cool, I’m exploring all these cities with zero inhabitants. Flying over all these empty freeways. Seeing semi trucks driving back and fourth through neighborhoods. Few vehicles there are may not even be on the correct side of the road.

I want to see believable residential traffic patterns, freeways dense with traffic density based on time but also there can be random jams, cities with dense and slow moving cars, vehicles who enter and exit the freeway, even vehicles who drive to a destination and park.

2 Likes

I would like dogs and cats. And birds. Lots of birds. Birds with accurate migratory patterns. And maybe snakes and bumblebees. And people walking around, and playing golf and football. Oh, and people riding bicycles. Let’s go for maximum immersion. It’s a flight simulator.

2 Likes

Hello PanelSystems,

I am an Object Oriented System Analisys and Object Oriented Programming college teacher with a masters degree in Applied Information Technology. Sorry for the curricullum, but for what I’m going to say it seems necessary.

At the moment, MSFS is a project far from finished, that obviously stepped over some important development phases to be released, actually, much sooner than the most optmistic enthusiast ever dreamed. As a result, the development team, which has finite resources (manpower, mostly) has to complete a series of tasks, like fixing bugs, adding planned but delayed funcionality and adding community requested features to name a few.

So this is the first aspect of the answer to your question: Is real-time traffic such an important feature to warrant displacing development resources from other tasks, say for example, fixing the countless bugs like autopilot, CTDs, unnatainable achievements and activities and so forth? If this software was launched with the level of reliability as its predecessors, I wouldn’t have written this post. But, as a personal note, if all you want is some eye candy, I’d rather have aviation relataded eye-candy, like contrails, vortexes and adiabatic expansion clouds (those clouds that sometimes form over the wing of taking-off jets) and an instant replay funcionality (which actually is much easier to implement and takes almost no computation resources).

The second aspect to your answer is that everything shown on the screen has some impact on computer performance, no matter how small the impact is. Adding complexity to the traffic simulation will invariably take resources from the computer to calculate the simulation and “generating fps” in the long run.

3 Likes

Guys,

Are we forgetting how amazing this simulator looks? Do any of us remember how we dreamed for decades to have Google Maps implemented on our favorite flight simulator?

I still can’t get enought from flying over places I visited IRL and noticing, even down here in South America, how mindboglingly accurate they are! They messed up my house and my negbourhood? Who cares? I can still see my building printed as a ground texture. How awsome is that?! And I don’t live in Rio de Janeiro!

and so on what
you were beginning to say something lol

They say that powerlines and more items that make VFR flying more navigable will be implemented.

I literally agree with every single thing you said
they are all settings you’re able to toggle on and off and the data is downloaded as you fly anyways.

This is the type of message-board conversation we need to be having at this stage of the simulator. I do not think traffic is all that much eye-candy
when I am flying with my father, it is basically the only thing to look at on the ground while in the air
it’s the only moving thing on planet earth (any mode of transportation for that matter). I think it is vital to the success of a recreation of the planet.

No, I don’t think this is more important than issues that are more important. I think this is more important than issues that are less important. That\s how important it is and will be.

Contrails, vortexes, and adiabatic clouds sounds amazing
instant replay will be out within the next few months I’m sure of it.

“Everything has some impact on computer performance” that is why almost all settings are almost fully-adjustable and why we buy and develop better and better computers.

2 Likes

what is mindbogglingly here?
and these are not Google Maps btw


Actually you are correct. Your way of thinking is in direct agreement with advancement in computer simulation technologies


Well, when I daydream about something, I daydream about the best. To daydream about Bing Maps on a flight simulator is like daydreamming Windows IoT on a car’s infotainment system: It may even become a thing, but today no one even knows it exists.

And I still think it trully is mindbogglingly (thanks for the correction) awesome that I can fly VFR in Brazil. Anyone outside the U.S. and Europe will probably agree with me. Very few roads and geographic features were available outside these areas in the previous iterations of MSFS.

still nothing new. it’s old technology. go to googleearth press ctl+alt+a and “fly” vfr in Brazil
 it’s old technology but ok not for you