As you say, there is much speculation. I just personally found it doubtful that METAR implementation was the only cause of the changes we have seen. It may have aligned with other requirments though.
We need to move the debate beyond METAR vs MB, which has become sterile. I have no doubt that there were important reasons for the changes that were made and we continue to see incremental improvements. For a more fundamental change though, I think that calls for a re-think of what the ‘live’ environment should be. Which is more than just live weather. I made this thread to consider one possibility…