I appreciate the detailed answer. however you talk from a real life aviation point of view where the weather is indeed unpredictable. we dont have to do any of that in a simulator. the weather is supposed to always match the forecast data. sounds like you want the game weather to both be accurate and unpredictable to teach aviation safety. mhm we need options
I don’t disagree that we need options. I’m all for that. My goal is to educate and dispel a lot of repeated myths about how this works in a real-world context that is achievable in the sim (moreso than it ever has been).
But you’re misinterpreting my answer - it’s more unpredictable the farther away the forecast period is. The closer it gets, the more predictable it is. And we use observations (radar, METAR, and PIREP, generally in that order) in an even more predictable period, maybe zero to 10 minutes in the future, to very accurately make decisions in the moment, often while airborne.
no I get you but its unpredictable to real life not the game
and this all started because somehow using forecast data for the weather is bad
If you make it that unpredictable in the game, it basically eschews a lot of accessible tools that pilots use.
It’s not much different than saying “well we’re not actually at risk of an engine failure, and they’re too unpredictable, so why use engine gauges at all?”
Or sitting in a desk chair, we’re not actually getting vertigo, well most of us at least, so why use the tools like an attitude indicator.
Or airspeed - not 100% predictable in turbulence, or due to other performance factors so why use an airspeed indicator. A big needle that indicates somewhere between 100 and 130 should suffice.
No, we need the observations to make real-time decisions. The fact that we have computers that get us close enough to real-time is amazing. I’m pushing for more. But if folks want a choice to say “just give me the general version and make it pretty” and the ability to do so exists without hampering the former, go for it.
I just finished writing a treatise on why it is bad! ![]()
TL;DR — we need lightning and thunder back. That should be a simple fix, one would think. We used to have it in Live Weather, now it’s nowhere to be found.
If Asobo implemented METAR and radar and other observations that uses the data from MB and then exported that to other real world planning tools the weather in the sim would be equally predictable as the real weather right? The only issue is it doesn’t match those who uses VATSIM right?
The only reason i see that it needs to match the real world weather is that those online atc services uses another source of data.
If there were another online atc service that used the MB source of data the atc wouldn’t be an issue at all.
Generally speaking, yes. If they could provide a suite that is close enough to operational usability, like aviationweather.gov or Leidos, etc, then it would be close enough for most users.
However, we then go back to the way weather actually behaves compared to longer-range forecasts. Is the sim going to produce accurately-behaving (not just accurate looking) weather? I highly doubt it because in the end, it’s still generated from sine forecast somewhere (the power and data to model global weather from scratch doesn’t yet exist), the baseline generation is still going to be too broad at longer range, and it’s still going to jump dramatically when the subsequent update doesn’t match what actually happened (which perpetuates the cycle of things happening).
Either way, I think both of these ideas are immense lifts. I expect they’ll be able to figure out how to reduce lag and more smoothly blend injected real-world weather and render it better before they can come up with an accurate, useable standalone suite on their own.
Then i want to ask. Why were they needed to change the system we had pre su7 when we could use the local METAR weather around airports using both free and paid addons? If the only purpose is to make it compatible with an online atc service thats not even included in the core simulator?
I know it’s a free service but not all of the users need to use that to be able to enjoy the sim. I’m one of them.
I am seeing many good proposals in this topic as well as in others related to weather, with the intention to improve the Live Weather. Some users are really weather knowledgeable and are bringing sometimes complex solutions that require, from my perspective, re-writing the overall Live Weather engine. Asobo introduced al launch a very innovative (and I guess already complex) Live weather engine. Then between SU5 and SU7 they introduced big changes that completely changed the way Live weather was depicted. For me that was a regression for others an improvement. Anyway, Since SU7, 5 SUs have been implemented with few improvements to Live Weather. So I am wondering if it is in the plans of Asobo to re-write the overall Live Weather engine to integrate fully or even partially those complex proposals in order to get more accurate weather, better clouds depiction, better (or optional) METAR integration. I feel they are quite satisfied with actual Live Weather state, they have other priorities than re-wrinting such a complex module that is the Live Weather. I am not saying they will never do that, but if it happens I anticipate we’ll have to wait many SUs.
I feel it must be done together with seasons update if any. But i think seasons means terrain visuals only when those seasons actually exists because of the weather to begin with.
To be frank, that’s the other end of the spectrum I mentioned yesterday. Many users are focused on narrow, single-scenario usage. For instance, I guarantee the majority of virtual ATC/airline users only truly look at METAR at the destination and perhaps winds/temps aloft, and that’s it. So they call for timely accuracy to that specific end.
On another end, there are users who prioritize the visual aesthetic, regardless of accuracy in behavior or matching real world conditions. Some folks actually eschew geo/temporal-spatial accuracy in weather, which I have repeatedly caution heavily against based on my experience and education in the subject.
I’m looking for both, well all of it, really, and my goal, the reason I stick around in these threads, is there’s too much hyperfocus and/or groupthink coming from each side without evidence of true understanding of the big picture from many. The subject matter is much bigger and deeper than the individual bits of knowledge many users bring to the table via requests, wishlists, bug reports, and discussion.
So I’m here to offer what I can, take it or leave it: why aviation weather is important to understand, how weather works, the risks involved, how aviation weather products work, how they’re used in real life and how they can be interpreted in a realistic sim experience. Where I fall short is the ability to under-the-hood system design and code this, so I defer to others on that aspect.
That said, the existing weather system is extremely close to being completely, realistically useable, so let’s draw back from focusing on METAR, METAR, METAR, and SU7, and talk about why all the accuracy is important going forward - aesthetic and geospatial, forecast and observation, and everything in between. Again, you can listen to someone with experience and education and move forward with solutions or you can keep guessing and romanticize a fairly single-use past that didn’t work in many ways, for many users.
Can the weather be fixed to everybody’s satisfaction? What would make that possible? How can we fix the rendering in parallel to that solution? They don’t need to be viewed as mutually exclusive.
Both sides can be satisfied, but it’s going to take them getting out of their respective entrenched positions and come to a deeper understanding. I wish more subject matter experts would speak up.
And I absolutely agree that seasons are a must.
Thats why i often mention options. Options introduce multi-scenario usage. For example, to get the sim weather in a fully dynamic experience and at the same time be 100% accurate will take same amount of time to implement as it will take to make forecasts 100% accurate. If we could have 100% accurate weather in the sim, forecasts would already be 100% predictable. I know all of those sources has limitations. And you have also mentioned that right? That means if we use the forecasted weather only we also accept the limitations of that source while those that uses the observations source would accept the limitations of those sources.
I feel there is no wrong or right about all of this.
Either we preffer a fluid forecasted weather that only updates every 12 hour without interuptions or we preffer a less fluid system that updates several times per day. There is no perfect solution until there exists 100% predictable weather.
For you the more accurate observation weather feels like weather, for me the more fluid/varied forecasted weather felt more like weather.
And I would respond to say that’s an overly general statement. PilotEdge is far more VFR friendly than VATSIM, and as you well know, enroute weather matters a lot to VFR pilots.
I can’t speak to the accuracy of MeteoBlue forecasts and current conditions in the LA area because I don’t live there, but MeteoBlue is usually accurate for where I do live. I can only assume that MeteoBlue is also accurate for the LA area.
As it stands, the game often doesn’t match MeteoBlue in the LA area, and since the PilotEdge controllers presumably expect it to be close to the (presumably correct) MeteoBlue conditions, that’s a problem. What I have to do then is use custom weather and advise the controllers that I have “information Zulu” (code for when flying with custom weather).
FL340, headed North and currently between Haiti and the Bahamas, lightning almost made me fall out of my chair I haven’t seen it in so long.
Sky is lighting up but graphically, it looks absolutely terrible!!!
the entire argument for accurate (aviation) weather only applies to multiplayer. for planning single player + ai flights you only have to use the meteoblue forecast and if the data is injected correctly the game weather will 100% match and be accurate to that source. why are single players forced to stay within the limits of 3rd party platforms like vatsim and pilotedge?
then that is a bug and should be reported. why is it not matching the source?
So true. And i wonder how much percent of MSFS users actually use VATSIM? If it were 100% of the userbase i would understand the forced change. But only if VATSIM changed their source they control against to MB source.
I use fshud offline based. And i love that. I think you mentioned that in another thread and needed to try and i loved it. Especially 1.3 BETA. Used pilot2atc before. Still use that while flying VFR though.
Both of those uses METAR based sources but i accept if those METARS are wrong because i know MSFS using MB as source. And even that those tools using METAR i would use the MB source only if that were possible to choose. I can just check their webpage and what i see there should match the sim weather. And it does most of the time but since they introduced METAR the weather feels same every single flight.
And i agree we should have reported that the weather didn’t match MB source when it didn’t match the MB source. I did after release 2020 at the place they said we should report bugs (zendesk) but instead they added METAR because of votes on the forum.
Weather feels the same because METARS all use the same general parameters for their data. Truly fluid dynamic weather does not. It follows it’s own mind. METAR takes free flowing weather and confines it into parameters that in and of themselves can become quite restrictive. Difference between putting your dog on a leash versus letting it run free. On the leash you can keep your dog where you want it to go and know the general direction. Off the leash there’s a million different things that can happen. There are only so many variations of METAR that can be produced based within those restrictions or parameters.
But we have the choice to choose if we want to let it run free or have the dog on a leash in the real world. Sometimes we don’t feel the need to have it on a leash. But in this sim all of the users needs to be restricted.
If they open it up we will only see METAR based addons. Asobo tried something different for once and i think that were the last time we will see that thing.
Those will set same ”preset” globally.
There’s plenty of bleating about it already. There’s even some evidence that it depends on which server you happen to be getting your weather from. All that bleating hasn’t budged anything anywhere though, so we sit here and discuss it amongst ourselves instead.