Very disappointed, but not surprised, that again there was nothing about weather at all in the latest Q&A.
How we can we get these issues to reach the devs and hear from them on it?
Very disappointed, but not surprised, that again there was nothing about weather at all in the latest Q&A.
How we can we get these issues to reach the devs and hear from them on it?
By switching the focus away from new planes and scenery improvements and more towards the functionality of the sim. There’s more money to be made from new planes and scenery/airports than making weather accurate, ATC bearable, and anything else function related.
I just wish the thing that made me buy this sim in the first place be focused on and that thing is the weather/atmosphere. But that thing has got worse and worse since release and now feels and looks less like an atmosphere than it did at release. That makes me dissapointed. Well, i can for sure see they focus much to improve avionics and stuff but that doesn’t make an aircraft fly. A simple paperplane can fly that doesn’t have any kind of avionics at all but the atmosphere needs to be correctly simulated to make that paperplane behave like a paperplane does in an atmosphere. And that atmosphere should look, feel and behave like an atmosphere for all types of aircraft because that would make the sim feel more realistic for everyone that uses this sim not only those that uses those specific aircraft that uses those types of avionics. I know avionics is a big part of aviation but it’s not needed to make an aircraft fly. The weather is there without avionics in use. My own thoughts about this. I really hope they will start focus on the weather that would increase the realism and experience for all of the users even those users that use aircraft without advanced avionics and planning tools in the future. I want the weather to feel like the weather did for those that made a flight for the first time long time ago that didn’t needed the weather to be set in stone because weather tools said the weather were in a specific state until the next report came in.
I still hoping to see a big update for the weather engine. But my expectations of the weather engine has dropped much since release 2020 and more hoping to get a revert or the old engine we had atleast right before su7 back as an optional feature than an update of the current engine.
I think we all have tried to explain the issues well but it’s hard without knowing exactly how the weather engine works. I think it’s up to the devs now to show some real progress of the atmospheric behaviour and make it much more varied and organic feel.
I’m really looking forward to that.
Back to writing here after gave up after the loss of gusts in SU4… it’s really frustrating that weather and core sim aspects are not a “resident” topics and ACTIVELY discussed in each development Q&A (as a minimum!). We are still a far cry from have a BI-DIRECTIONAL communication with the developers. It’s really like a statistical artillery here, blindingly posting and shooting questions and no way to know that it will ever get answered, and cleary we don’t.
I don’t want to make this a rambling post so I will just thank again to all of devoted people here that keep the fundamental topics alive ![]()
The only POSITIVE hint I saw, is that they might open the weather API for 3rd party… If I got the message correctly… here it is (Jorg words “why we are even blocking this”…)
If we can have a true and complete OPEN weather API in the sim, it will be a huge step for sure!
EDIT - timestamp is 1:12:37, timestamp doesn’t seem to work for some reason
Maybe, but what i think will happen is that we will only see METAR based weather that we have had since ever. Active sky use that and could see a review on that for xplane 12 and that user that reviewed it praised how accurate it were when active sky removed high level clouds because the METAR said CAVOK but CAVOK doesn’t mean completely clear sky but for sim pilots it means completly clear sky and says it’s more accurate than have some high level clouds visible. Meteoblue seamless weather were something new and different. Some liked it and some dislikes. We will never have that type of weather again because it were completely ruined in su7 in my opinion. And if they make the weather open for 3rd parties we will not see more updates i bet of the default weather because they will not see the point improve it. The weather engine we had at release i would says is gone. Some feels that is good that check those weather tools and want the weather accurate to those and some like me feels it worse because the seamlessnes and organic feel is gone.
Ya know, in the end, if they had just fixed the timing meteoblue might have been OK. I don’t recall anyone griping “I broke out at 205’ when the metar said OVC 200 1/2 RA”, what I was experiencing was “OVC 200 1/2 RA but the depiction in the sim is completely clear.”
I think (if memory serves) that was something to do with relying on a meteoblue model that was like 12 hours offset or something? Had they fixed that things might have been fine without going down the METAR bubble path.
The thing that makes me the most sad is that we actually had options to use METAR based weather pre su7. REX (not free) or Unreal weather (free) 3rd party tools that we could use if we needed the weather to stay as METAR reported. Now we have no options without the METAR to disturb. Will be same when they open it up for 3rd parties.
Weather was truly amazing at back then no doubt, many aspects were better than today and it surely felt more natural. I really hope we could get all the good parts of it we had back then. It’s really not a matter of this or that, it’s about flexibility and continuous improvement. Both are missing.
METAR can have it place, but only if correctly implemented and anyway, kept as an OPTION.
As for weather API, the ability to inject or override some of current weather states/parameters , injecting winds/turbulence etc could augment and enhance missing features or behaviors. At least this could provide some workaround till being added to the core engine. I’m sure they can come up with some solution. From what I understand, It doesn’t sounds like they are giving up on developing the weather.
Actually even better, just like Working Title did for avionics… wish we had a Working Weather Title dedicated group
… with the same level of expertise, capabilities , enthusiasm and communication ![]()
![]()
![]()
I really wish we had a toggle option in the sim to use full meteoblue weather like we had at release, it was so pretty and the smooth transitions were gorgeous
Same. Can’t seeing something like that coming along for quite a long time.
What ruined it in the end were people going to real life metar services and weatherstations or looked outside their windows and complained that the weather in sim wasn’t the same as what they saw reported.
To this day, I still don’t get why people need the weather in the sim be the exact copy of what’s outside the sim. Maybe for VATSIM purposes, but as Perry rightfully pointed out, we had METAR based 3rd party addons pretty much from the get go.
I still don’t understand why Asobo didn’t include in-sim weather reporting features, that would report the weather at a given observing and reporting station in-sim. That would have quelled the desire to check real world stations only to complain about the discrepancies.
Yesterday we had some heavy rain, massive clouds, was eager to get home and try some cloud surfing.
Lol, in the sim there was some clouds, one here another there… So disappointing…
the game real weather has stopped looking close to outside the window for 2 years since metar. not many seem to care for that now so why did they do it. when we want to ask the devs its silence and secrecy and shutting down of discourse. it tells me there is other reaons behind it than vatsim. does vatsim realize how innacruate the clouds are. do they care? I think not
Well, i have come to the conclusion that there is only accuracy that matters in flight simulators. Then how it looks and feels doesn’t matter at all. They could reimplement pictures as clouds instead because to me the volumetric clouds has no purpose in flight simulators because the weather needs to fixed for 30 minutes anyway. Why did we change cloud textures in older sims? Because after some time it got repetive. Same thing with the clouds in the sim right now. After some time it gets repetive because it’s generic now because they needed to make the global forecasted weather fit the static for 30-60 minutes local weather reports.
I know that Meteoblue inject data from those weatherstations into the mb weather model and that thing caused the weather feel generic. Exactly what is causing it nobody besides Asobo or Meteoblue knows for sure.
I think this weather engine Asobo used at release were meant to be used with a forecasted weather model only.
Right or wrong decission? Who has the correct answere? I would say it’s right. It’s a simulated weather that not always are accurate to what will happen in the real life. Is it just random weather? Nope, it were weather that were simulated using real world initial conditions.
The only photo of the 4 that stands out to me is the first one that doesn’t have volcanic looking clouds. All the rest I have had similar or same depictions in SU11/12.
If they would just go back to the original cloud shading model that produced lighter and more blue shadows instead of this darker more yellow/almost black colorations that we get now… It’d be much better imo – but I really don’t think they are even aware that they made a change.
Even xplane is getting a massive overhaul soon, including cirrus clouds.
Fingers crossed this will make Asobo do it as well.
Yeah, i use both sims and like them both. I really like the development progress of the atmosphere in xp12. I think soon xp12 will be ahead of MSFS weather that i found to be superior before su7 were released.
They do not set weather fixed as METAR says. They use forecast models (NOAA) and i like that approach. Thats the future of flight simulators.
I think soon VATSIM needs to use the forecasted data too to keep up.
Developers of flight simulators need to find a way to simulate observations of the sim weather instead of set weather to be fixed as METAR says. The weather should flow while the observations should be static.
no no no… metar data is the best what Asobo done, using live weather I want to have excatly weather condition on airports, during take off and landings… Forecast models could be beetwen ( on the road) metars… we had that forecast models everywhere from start MSFS and it was very weak on airports… METAR data must stay as it is !