Do you have the same issue if you follow the OP’s steps to reproduce it?
NO
Provide extra information to complete the original description of the issue:
Full rich mixture works when you’re at sea level or relatively low altitude. One of the possible issue you’re facing is that you set full rich, on ground but at a location where temperature and altitude are high. In this condition, the mixture should be leaned to have the maximum power (and rpm). That’s Density Altitude. I have personally no issue reaching max rpm on the regular MSFS Cessna 172. Let us know the result of a test where you set full rich on a field at sea level with a outside temperature around 15 to 20 degrees Celsius. Obviously, it could be another reason. For example, joystick/throttle settings.
@Vincent1064 i was at Key West airport and it was with the G1000 C172. I didn’t have any issues with the other C172. Everything worked just fine. I also use the Xbox controller since I don’t have a throttle or joystick.
@Lgdeaf, @MRTNAIRLINES, I see you voted for this topic. Which 172 variant are you seeing this on? At what airport and mixture setting are you seeing this at? Do you have any mods installed?
@N316TS I have the NXi Mod, Airport Enhancement Mod, and the Airport Environment Mod. I’m going to a full reinstall to see if that helps. Again the other C172 (non G1000) worked just fine.