Just my blunt thinking, and i mean for if its possible, but thinking out of the xbox,
Cant you not hook the xbox up via a direct lan cable with a pc or thinclient pc and hook this up via pc second lan to modem connected to internet
In the lan/ethernet software give xbox permission to connect via lan with internet. And if this would be possible run extra software somewhere in between.
I mean it is possible to connect wii controllers on pc while you need candles on both of the screen but possible it is.
Like i said it is just an idea and question of me, or is it me thinking on a wrong path.
Me is pc user, but i feel with xbox users for this beautifull hobby which they so enthousiastly introduced for xbox.
Full disclaimer: I am a PC simmer, but i owned a previous generation Xbox, so have some idea about how the Xbox ecosystem works.
Now, coming to the problem at hand, I think many of these apps can be made to run as part of sim via wasm module or even JS module may be. But currently the problem with that is that these apps are not newly developed addons, they are quite old codebase and vatsim/fseconomy for example is free and is developed by volunteers.
-
They will need significant investment in time and effort to port these apps from native to wasm format. Plus, without actually trying it first, there any be many limitations, (some of them are already known, for example an wasm module cannot really access any arbitrary storage area due to security reasons), which may hinder development after spending significant effort (like ms / Asobo didn’t realize xbox can’t run wasm modules when the pmdg dc6 was launched first and that took them more than a year to resolve), although they can atleast start on a pc environment to see if such a proof of concept works or not.
-
Running apps natively has some other advantage like it cannot crash the sim if the app behaves in a bad way
-
there may be a way to run some thin client as a wasm module and allow users to run native app somewhere in the local network on a separate pc, but these workflow may become very clunky for casual users
-
running these apps natively in xbox should be technically possible as as of current gen, xbox is using x86_64 CPU like our PC and using an OS that’s is windows at its core. But this is a business dicision to not allow it to be run as pc and thus limit it’s distribution options to Xbox store (their source of income from the Xbox ecosystem)
-
Dev environment is another hurdle, everyone don’t get access to Xbox devkits or developer mode (I don’t this process at all)
-
Distribution is another issue, xbox and flightsim marketplace has many stardards which are suppos d to be enforced. Developers may not want to adhere to these standards. Plus there is not really a freeware category at the moment in the MSFS marketplace (although there are some free libraries from 3rd parties)
All in all, I think the progress on xbox flight simming has been really great considering it’s been just 2.5 years. Pc flight simming experience has been progressing for more than 40 years at this point, so obviously Xbox has a lot of catching up to do.. and that’s not going to happen in just 1-2 years. Give it a generation or 2, may be by 2030, you will be able to all the things that pcs are doing now. I know that’s frustrating to hear but progress does take time.
I have exactly the same hope ![]()
That’s my point (I asked many developers about it and they explained exactly the same arguments)
That’s an absolutely realistic explanation of causes… Microsoft should do a statement in this terms
i’d really like to know why a lot of the apps i use externally requires FSUIPC if simconnect exists. I’m hard pressed to believe it’s “developer choice.” FSUIPC (and by extension XPUIPC) seems like the kind of app that gets created when the default API isn’t sufficient…
FSUIPC was created before a time where there was a SimConnect, and modified the memory of FlightSim itself to alter and read sim values. Some developers learned to use that decades ago and still prefer it.
FSUIPC actually uses SimConnect itself now under the hood (nor more direct memory mangling).
Just like an iPhone cannot run arbitrary apps that are not signed by Apple (without jailbreak), XBox users live within a walled garden.
To have external apps running is impossible, and to modify them for use on consoles would take a long time and cost to develop. Perhaps someone one day will be up to the task, but I could almost guarantee they won’t be free.
I would expect the best way to proceed perhaps would be to hope a future MSFS will natively support these features one day.
That’s a target MS/Asobo must aim for. I don’t think anyone is really suggesting getting VATSIM up and running on Xbox but it’s almost certainly possible to develop something similar, particularly if they seek assistance from a third-party.
Plenty of people have suggested vatsim for xbox across the Internet (here, reddit, vatsim forums etc).
If MS allows Asobo and third party devs to run these PC-based apps on console, they’ll have to let others mod their games as per the needs of their respective comminities. We can call it payware or add-ons or extensions or whatever but native support or not they are still mods. I literally cannot think of another console game on the market that you could “legally mod” like FS without either breaking some sort of ToS or requiring an additional 1000 hours of work to implement. The “all you gotta do to implement is…” argument only goes so far.
But we can hope all we want. I won’t discount what a steam-like workshop on console would do for PC competition at large…
Then, is possible and the key is the balance between costs of implementation vs. revenues, and the XBox share of market is huge
you missed the point bud, it’s just not about cost to benefit. Of course it’s about making money, but it’s also about making money while spending as little of it as possible. i’d wager that C-suite execs at MS would find it too costly. That is: Someone still has to get paid for those 1000 hours of work (likely many many more).
My point was MS would have to allow such implementation on xbox for everyone, not just flight sim app devs. And that opens the door to all sorts of potential security issues. Sure, we could still analyze it and put in something that alleviates, but like i said before, C-Suite execs are going to look at all the costs involved.
Plus, i’d also imagine that would drive up the costs of the console itself if it theoretically could run apps like GSX or connect to vatsim.
Again, it is a question of balancing the costs of investing tangible and intangible resources in the developments vs. the benefits that this investment could generate. Given the size of the Xbox user market, this would not seem negligible.
There should be no increase in the Xbox simulator, as today it costs the same as the PC version and offers considerably less. If the console should not raise its price as the hardware is more than enough in the X-Series (said by developers). If a paid addon would be needed to manage the logics of these “external” connections for all games, it could be absolutely understandable and attractive to users.
It’s a question of how Microsoft values the Xbox Simmers market.
That FS2024 is being developed with Xbox in mind should answer that.