I am not unsympathetic to people on the other side of the Tasman, most of them that I know personally have the best internet they can, and itās pretty bad. I guess Iām lucky that our government invested heavily and well over 10 years ago in our fibre network. Now in Christchurch, the standard minimum fibre speed is 200/30.
However, that is not Microsoftās fault. The system requirements indicated that a quality internet connection was needed for most services and that the minimum was 5Mbps, with the recommended speed of 50Mbps.
Unfortunately, your request is not practical from a financial or logistical standpoint, and hereās whyā¦
-
The cost of producing flash drives with MSFS on it would get very expensive, especially if you needed a new drive for every update (one per month). I suppose they could burn DVDs, but they are going out of fashion and most new computers donāt have drives on them
-
The update cycle is one core release per month. That release is usually bundled with a World Update, Sim Update or other. Because of how the development pipeline works, they wouldnāt be able to start producing media until about the time of or after the digital versions update. This means you wouldnāt be able to use the simulator until you installed the update, which could take hours or days to ship depending on supply vs demand
-
Delivery times to the Pacific would make it pointless as you wouldnāt get your device for 5 to 10 days if you paid for priority shipping, or one to three weeks if you didnāt pay for better shipping. Add to that current shipping restriction, the recent port strikes and the general delays at our respective borders and your media not arrive until after the next update.
MSFS is an MMO and relies heavily on online cloud services (weather, traffic, scenery, content downloads, multiplayer etc). It is standard for an MMO to force core updates on users, and that is exactly what happens here.
You can choose to download optional content (aircraft, bespoke airports, world updates) and their updates, but you cannot and I canāt imagine you will ever get the choice to opt-out of core updates.
Those DVDs are an old build, most likely release or a pre-release version. Anyone who installs from the DVD version should expect to download massive updates. They are not a viable option for skipping the digital download.
I donāt want to seem mean, but why do people use the car metaphor so willingly here? Iāve seen it a lot, but no one has managed to pull it off well, people should really choose an appropriate metaphor.
āif a component for your car is delivered broken, wouldnāt you expect a replacement?ā - Yes, but only if:
a) The car was still in warranty
b) The fault was their fault, not mine, or not someone elseās
If my first car a 1998 Hyundai Accent (assuming it still exists) had a mechanical defect, I wouldnāt expect the manufactures to replace a part. Now if my grandparents new 2019 cars tiers suddenly burst, I might expect the dealer to replace them but not if the reason they were damaged is because the roads are rough from all the earthquakes.
If your simulator was a car, itās tires are broken because your government hasnāt made a modern internet connection available to the masses (assuming you live in a major town/city), or because you brought a city car for driving in the country where no roads exist. Neither of these is the car manufactures fault.