great write up… and Id agree with the points you make.
I do think it’s a shame, that sometimes developers are overly ‘defensive’.
Ive also got BeyondATC and unfortunately, whilst I think their videos dont come across as pushy as SAI, their discord/community moderators are just as defensive.
why is overly defensive bad?
( and don’t get me wrong, Im a developer and its an easy trap to fall into, I do it at times too, - and Ive known other developers doing the same )
a) it can come across as passive aggressive, not a good look to your (or potential) customers.
b) if your not careful you fall into the trap of justification, rather than listening.
you are better to just thank for the feedback and move on…
(and yes, again, as a passionate dev, that is much easier to say than do
)
back on topic… though,
after playing with BeyondATC more, Im actually considering moving back (and subscribing) to SayIntentions, despite my criticisms above…
why?
opensky/skynet - I think the multiplayer side of SAI is going to be very enjoyable.
(this is not something BATC are doing, they believe BATC is a single player experience)
whilst I had issues with SAI getting approaches wrong, and initially felt BATC was better at this - Ive also been experience similar issues with BATC.
so Im starting to think neither are ‘perfect’ , so perhaps SAI flexibility is actually the better trade off.
BATC is not as cost-free (once purchased) as it seems…
Ive been getting a lot of issues with the ‘Basic (no cost)’ voice engine, and the response I got from support was “we cannot guarantee response from this free service”, basically, buy premium voices if you want full reliability!
… and that brings us back to the price of SAI, and subscription model.
as @StudentWolke4 points out above.
whilst there are free LLM/Speech services available, they all have caveats on usage, you exceed this, the service at a minimum degrades.
so to get something reliable, you (or your provider BATC/SAI) have to pay, so the sub model is unavoidable.
soo… is SAI worth it? thats the issue…
at the moment it feels high cost for what it provides, but hopefully it means they also paying that on for a decent SLA on the services they use.
its a tough one, esp, as we are getting inundated with everyone wanting us to subscribe, but it does feel like your getting what you pay for here.