SU7 Breaks the Laws of Physics for Helicopters on Elevated Pads

ISSUE DESCRIPTION

Description of the issue:

In SU7, spawning in with a helicopter on an elevated helipad reveals a severe disruption to the CFD model. Ground effect (or turbulence from terrain) on the elevated pad appears to be massively magnified, causing a huge overspeed in the rotor RPM. When attempting to land at an elevated pad, the helicopter will encounter that magnified force and will be flung up into the air.

Small update: the issue remains in SU7.1 Beta 1.9.20.0

FREQUENCY OF ISSUE

How often does this occur for you (Example: Just once, every time on sim load, intermittently)?

Since SU7, always.

REPRODUCTION STEPS

Please list clear steps you took in order to help our test team reproduce the same issue:

  1. In Free Flight, spawn in with Cabri G2 at EGLT ‘The Needles Lighthouse Helipad’.

  2. Use Alt+6 to reveal “extreme turbulence intensity” is currently caused principally by “terrain”

  3. Even when stationary, with the collective down, observe that the rotor speed increases far beyond the acceptable limit.

UPDATE 1: on further testing, I found that I can reduce (but not eliminate) the effect by reducing Assistances > Turbulence from ‘Realistic’ to ‘Low’. To reproduce this problem, I suggest checking that live weather is ‘On’ and Turbulence is ‘Realistic’.

YOUR SETTINGS

If the issue still occurs with no mods and add-ons, please continue to report your issue. If not, please move this post to the User Support Hub.

What peripherals are you using, if relevant:

[PC Only] Are you using Developer Mode or have you made any changes to it?

[PC Only] What GPU (Graphics Card) do you use?

[PC Only] What other relevant PC specs can you share?

MEDIA

I made this demo to illustrate the issues in SU7 with elevated helipads.

Had a wierd experience with the H500C on a mountain yesterday, during a Career Mode SAR, where it took off on its own with the collective fully down and I also experienced some rotor speed spikes :thinking:

But I’m not sure if it was caused by the usual MSFS exaggerated turbulence (it was somewhat windy, despite the METAR report of zero knots), or if it was some of these SU7 shenanigans :person_shrugging:

EDIT - There was a report in the devsupport forum that the miscalculated drag on SU7 also affected the rotor blades drag, so its speed was increased.

Not just helipads. I would say all object in the game, which are not terrain. Yesterday i was flying around my home, and for some reason, i lost lift completely. So i added collective and moved like 20cm from the spot and i was skyrocketing.

I experienced the same this morning with the 500C, sitting on the ground rotor rpm in the green when all of a sudden the rotor RPM skyrocketed, May have been a gust of wind however have never noticed this previously. Also once coming in to land near sea level the rotor rpm suddenly increased again and was sustaining level flight even with the collective fully down then all of a sudden went back to normal. (I didn’t catch it in time, was a slammer lol)

Yeah, I had to repair the “landing gear” after that mountain flight :sweat_smile:

It’s been around “forever” this issue, not sure yet if SU7 really made it worse:

Hi! It was fixed in SU5 but now, in my experience, it is far worse in SU7. Please consider upvoting this bug report if you haven’t already. Thank you! :blush:

Thanks for sharing your experience. In SU7, I have been noticing many instances of excessive rotor RPM (possibly due to greatly magnified ground effect) while on any structure that is not a runway, taxiway, apron, etc. Please consider upvoting this bug report if you haven’t already. :blush:

There’s an older Needles helipad discussion suggesting this ground-effect issue existed before SU7. Has anyone compared rotor RPM at EGLT using the same helicopter and weather conditions in SU6 versus SU7? That would help identify what actually changed.

Also with the H145 from HPG, most of the time uncontrolable prior to land .

Oh dear, I was chasing ghosts yesterday while encountering those, as an observation, the wind dramatically changes around the helipads on those oil rigs.

I encountered this with the MB105 when attempting to land on a moving ship, something I do a lot. Since SU7 a giant updraft forced me skyward as I came under ground effect. At first I thought the winds were exceptional but it soon became clear something was badly wrong! Another approach to my regular raised hospital pad gave similar results.

There is now a report in the devsupport forum that SU7.1 doesn’t solve this issue, so it probably isn’t “drag” related but something else that was introduced in SU7.

https://devsupport.flightsimulator.com/t/su7-engine-performance-or-drag-is-wrong/18609/38

I find it happening also on ridges, etc, is related to the updrafts and downdrafts maybe?

Hope they can fully fix this for SU7.1

Probably, I’ve had problems with mountain landings since SU7.

ISSUE DESCRIPTION

Description of the issue: When you fly over the pickup or drop-off points with helicopters at cargo missions, there is a fake turbulence over the point.
I’m not sure if it is intentional or just the sim messing up the model of the sim object, but it makes the mission so much harder than usual.
This can be observed for the H225 as well, haven’t tried with other helicopters, but I guess this is a general bug that affects every helicopter in the sim.

Scenario:

  • Step one: approaching drop-off ship: no turbulence
  • Step two: Closer to platform: light turbulence by terrain
  • Step three: a few feet closer: moderate turbulence - Lift starting to disappear
  • Step four: a few more feet closer: severe turbulence - Lift is gone
  • Step five: crash into the deck

Power is relatively stable, of course corrections are in place. There’s nothing under the helicopter, only the ship, so no terrain.

Uploaded the video for demonstration and analysis:

FREQUENCY OF ISSUE

Every time

REPRODUCTION STEPS

Please list clear steps you took in order to help our test team reproduce the same issue:

  1. Load a heli cargo mission

  2. Fly over the object of pickup or dropoff

  3. Optionally turn on CFD visualizations

YOUR SETTINGS

Irrelevant, my only setting is frustration…

I would really like to upgrade from beta tester to simple user…

MEDIA

Step one:

Step Two:

Step Three:

Step Four:

Made a video demonstrating the behavior, this is honestly a joke now. Do they call this a finished product? What happened to testing? Or are we the testers now?

Just tested the Cabri at the EGLT helipad, seems like the issue was fixed there, independently tested some other platforms, they seem to be fine, looks like only these mission generated assets have this issue, experiencing it during Hoist rescue missions as well, over the lifeboat of the lost person.

no that is not my experience. I have the issue also with h125 in freeflight. The heli-pad literally repulsed me and i flew upwards with collective completely down when i tried to land.