I don’t believe it’s been tested, really. It seems to be pretty bad and so I think it’s been given the briefest of looks before being put on the marketplace. Again, from a cynical point of view, to generate a lot of sales due to a glaring gap in the Xbox market.
Not saying it’s the fault of the developer. They’ve done all they can really, I think.
What? Assuming something works and hope for the best without ever testing is the best they can do? If that is the state of addon development, I‘m out.
Same issue on PC… lol
Before they approve any more third party stuff they need to address this.
Good to know. Hopefully this is just a temporary annoyance. It’ll no doubt affect the sales.
It has already affected sales. They sold more releasing it in broken state than not releasing it.
That PMDG would succeed in releasing a working 737 on Xbox is probably just a dream after this debacle.
Why would they even want to risk their reputation and development costs in trying.
Trash-Developers do not care but the big ones can live well from the PC market alone and have a reputation to lose and lots of development and support costs are at risk.
Of course this can all get resolved in the future, but right now, why would they risk it again or any big-name developer with complex aircraft.
Chris Powell from PMDG has stated in their forums that they have reached out to MS and that solving these issues is their top priority. Hopefully all parties will learn from this and not make the same mistake with the 737. This is just a temporary annyance that will be fixed soon (hopefully).
I don’t envisage a quick fix, personally. Given how long it takes them to approve updates.
Cheers. It’s good that they’re on the case, at least.
I’ll personally be holding off on purchasing it, for now. Just to see what happens. I know from reviews It’s a very good aircraft but there’s something not quite right when third party addons translate to the Xbox. They (Asobo) need to identify and sort that out before I’ll be willing to spend nearly 50 quid on an aircraft.
Really? that’s the best course of action? It’s a bug they’re probably all running around like crazy trying to fix, have some patience…
Sorry I don’t have. This is not a bug, this product (the DC-6) is completely broken and cannot be flown. Like delivering a new car without tires and asking for patience because they will come sometime in the future. One can admire the looks in the meantime. How is that acceptable?
A bug is a specific instrument that might work or a flight model with oddities. The DC-6 is simply not in a state that should be on sale.
As a retired test engineer … my job was to test the product from head to toe to make sure it did what the company says it doses. I designed tests to stress the product. I designed tests to reflex the real world use of the product. No product to prefect off the design floor.
I have no idea what the work flow of PMDG thru to Asobo is. But good engineering practice should have stress testing at all stages of the product design to sales.
Bottom line for me…
I own a xbox s. I know and understand the limits of the xbox. I always assume a few issues. I’m a very forgiving person as I understand the tack at hand. BUT and this is a very large BUT if you are going to charge folks premium prices they and i will assume a premium product. You PMDG and Asobo have my money and I do not have the premium product you promised. Companies only get one (1) shot at me. Maybe in the distance future I’ll come back to PMDG but I’m very very disappointed today.
dw
This isn’t the second time you @ me. Please don’t.
Incidentally, this situation proves my point. The DC-6, despite being one of the best add-ons for the sim in general, has a pretty low rating (3 stars) on the marketplace because it doesn’t work correctly for a number of Xbox users.
As a matter of fact, it has a lower rating than some addons that are complete trash.
This shows a couple of things.
1: There’s a large subset of users who aren’t used to the endemic issues of launching complex aircraft in a flight simulator (even more so on a new platform) and react knee-jerk without patience for them to be fixed. And some of the reactions in this very thread should show you what I mean. Some want new aircraft, but they’re not willing to support developers who try as soon as some snag happens. That’s a crying shame, really.
2: More importantly, there are large obstacles for third-party developers in properly testing their products on Xbox before they’re released, with results that must not be pleasant for any party involved.
In light of these facts, one really should not be surprised if there are developers that don’t want the headache and don’t bother.
PMDG wants to bother despite the clear difficulties, and that’s great of them. They certainly don’t deserve the negative reviews.
If 3 stars is the welcome Xbox users give one of the best devs in flight simulation despite the fact that the issues are out of their control, this certainly isn’t going to encourage other holdouts.
Took the words right out of my mouth. This is a great aircraft and instead of giving PMDG and Microsoft a few days to figure out what’s happening and fix it, they dog the product. If I were a third-party developer watching this from the sidelines I’d think twice about getting involved in XBox if even PMDG is having a difficult time keeping at bay those who asked for complex aircraft yet are unwilling to even give a few days for obviously unanticipated issues to be worked out. I don’t understand. Do these people really sit there and think the dialogue between PMDG and Microsoft went something like “Hmmmm… how can we made everyone upset right around holidays? Ya know what? Let’s just throw something up on there without testing it at all! That’s gonna have everyone happy! We don’t really care, after all, we just want money. Screw the community!” Come on… does anyone seriously think people didn’t try to deliver something problem-free?
I don’t know what this (above) means.
I’m just pointing out there is interest and more aircraft coming which maybe not you but others were certain would not be.
I agree it’s not gotten off to a good start but it will be fixed and all will be well. If it’s not fixed and soon we do have problems.
