Crash to desktop without error message

Sorry, yes, I’ve managed to fly it on 2 occasions

I have multiplayer disabled. And I dont consider the FBW 320 as classic community content any more as it is part of the marketplace (I installed it in game from the marketplace, not manually in the community folder).

Good afternoon to all pilots!

I continue to read the forum thread and noticed that messages from colleagues are divided into two large categories:

The first group has regular disruptions, CDT, and other pleasures. Moreover, the occurrence of these failures defies any reasonable explanation. To eliminate these failures, people from the first group follow a lot of both reasonable and completely fantastic recommendations, actually taken from nowhere.
The most interesting thing is that in the process of all these attempts and experiments, it can repeatedly seem that complete success has been achieved. The causal relationship between what is being done and the likelihood of success cannot be identified. And it really looks like a placebo effect, as one of the authors famously said just above.

In the second group, everything is fine in general (although it is a little embarrassing why they even read this thread). And they share the opinion that it is worth trying different realistic and not very options, often related not even to the settings of the simulator, but to the system environment or hardware components of the computer of citizens from the first group. Moreover, not always, but sometimes the emphasis is placed precisely on inept hands and a crooked executable environment.

Well, the cherry on top is that there are even some (very rare) representatives of this group, even the opinion is voiced that this is all normal, it should be so, because the fault lies with the losers themselves and their crooked hardware / programs.

And in general, the problem will disappear by itself, as if it never existed.

I belong to the first group of losers.
So, I report that the problem has not disappeared anywhere.

To be specific, my configuration is:

i7-10700kf (nominal frequency), matherboard PRIME Z490-A, 32Gb DDR4 Kingston XMP 4300, ASUS STRIX 2070S 8Gb, SSD SandiskG5 1Gb (with simulator only… sorry, Xpane (working) is there too)
MSFS Steam Edition Deluxe, Windows 10 20H2 (with all patch). NVidia 471.41

From the periphery - a lot of game controllers.

Well what can I say!
Before SU5, I had only literally one or two unexplained CTDs in a little over 500 hours (I did not fly long, only six months, since I was waiting for VR).

At the moment, I have a guaranteed CTD (0xC … 05) that occurs within 2-3 minutes after launch (and it doesn’t matter if I managed to launch the flight or rummage through the menu in search of the best settings.

I tried many options for fixing the problem, both my own and the suggested ones. By the way, by the way, I neatly cleaned the% UserName% \ AppData \ Roaming \ Microsoft Flight Simulator folder from unnecessary dlls, including from FBW, I have never seen such advice in the thread, if someone has already written, sorry :).

An empty community folder, of course. Tried launches from different regions of the world, different default aircraft.
It is clear that there is enough free disk space, free memory and video memory too, processor load (while it is possible to measure it) - a maximum of 15-20% (Video card - up to 100%)

I have done all sane and some not so sane but harmless advice.

Some advice, mainly from the field of hardware, I did not do, for example, I’m really not sure that disabling XMP and working at nominal memory frequencies is obviously more stable (although I would understand the advice to check the memory using memtest). However, it is unclear why, since in general everything else in the system works fine, including huge virtual machines with a complex environment (not launched simultaneously with the sim, of course :))

I also did not reinstall the sim and windows (I did the integrity control). I’ve seen a lot of people who weren’t helped by this.

I also didn’t turn off my usb controllers. I’ve also seen a lot of people who weren’t helped by this.
And if it helped me, why would I need a simulator without Joysticks? :slight_smile:

I am ready to easily assume any reason, for any failures, except one - the one that causes the crash right in the main menu.
Guys - this is really weird.

And this suggests that Asobo still has a problem.

Regards AlexFly

ps
I will support in this thread the trend of finding strange coincidences

  • The simulator crashes faster if developer mode is enabled (and the FPS window is open).
  • owners of Radeon video cards more often report successful problem solving than owners of NVidia cards

p.s.2
You will laugh, but while writing this sad post, PWatsonUK wrote the exact opposite - about the absence of CTD in developer mode and the FPS window :slight_smile:

p.s.3

Forgot to add:

I don’t always get dumped onto the desktop after two minutes.
Rarely, but it is possible to fly for fifteen minutes or even an hour.
And then it begins to seem that here it is - a miracle!

Just completed a flight. So my solution is a hardly a placebo because on each of at least 10 prior attempts I got a CTD. The only change was backing off all ulta graphics settings.

Prior to that the issue was simply loading the sim at all. Again I had no success on I would say each of 20 attempts. New graphics drivers allowed me to load the sim to the menus 100% of the time. Again, not a placebo effect.

I have tried lowering the graphics settings, assuming that the video memory used may be exceeded.
Unfortunately - it didn’t work for me

I’m not laughing, just reporting what I’ve found (so far)…

There does seem to at least two distinct categories of CTDs - Those that have them when loading/browsing menus/hitting ‘Fly Now’ and those that only experience them when actually flying. I’m in the latter camp, you’re in the former.

I have some sympathy for Asobo unpicking this mess given the wide variety of PC hardware, peripherals, installed software, sim variables etc but the common factor does seem to be SU 5? Perhaps they’ll release a patch with logging to gather info, or a standard config to try with graphics, locations, selected aircraft, weather, ToD etc all set for tests under common conditions?

Yes, there is certainly no laughing matter :sob:

It’s just a funny coincidence that you and I wrote about the developer mode effect at the same time. :grin:

Yes, my external disk is ExFat, my internal one is NTFS.

I also checked my old HDD that used to store MSFS and that one is also NTFS. That said, before update 5 there was no issue on my external SSD.

If i knew what a SATA cable was I would probably try it.

Forget it.
If you had an issue with your SATA cables (the cables carrying data from the HD/SSD to the main board), your OS would constantly crash as it keeps transferring all the time.

ExFat you might get away with however Fat32 no chance but anyway why ask for trouble? The same with external hard drives, the vast majority are intended for data portability not to run games from and mid flight MSFS having to wake it up every few minutes to search for scenery isn’t exactly ideal.

can confirm, GA Planes seem to work, Commercial jets suffer under CTDs.

Blockquote why ask for trouble?

Sadly my laptop’s internal SSD isn’t very large so I try to avoid installing too much stuff on it.

If you can borrow another drive or computer to back your existing files up to it would be good so that you can format your external one to NTFS and then simply copy your files back. Once done you will need to find a setting that stops your drive from sleeping or hibernating, I can’t help too much as I’m on windows 11 but google is always your friend.

Why did I say I wasn’t having CTDs?! Now I have frequent ones, once every 2 flights unfortunetely!
Sim is broken.

If you are using the NXi from the marketplace, try uninstalling it.

Only your main as with the right settings peripheral drives can be hotplugged. I must admit it’s unlikely out of the box.

all of these are mods… it makes not different where you get it from. We learned often enough, that mods from marketplace have the same “zero compatibility pre-check” than the “normal” community mods.

But not only the mods makes trouble. Dont forget the connected devices. There are reports from users with saitek devices, etc.

May be interessting for eg.:

Hi Micha,

Although I have never mentioned it, I have a Saitek Trim Wheel, as soon I use it to trim, I get an annoying pause where the simulator locks-up. Pre hot-fix patch for SU5 this was for around a minute. It does not cause a CTD however, I can now understand why some USB controllers might. The pause is now around 8 seconds with the hot-fix patch.

Charles.