[Polls] City Update 16: Italy

Poll Questions

Feel free to answer these poll questions after you download and experience the new update.

Was the download/install process smooth and free of issues? If you encountered any problems, please respond to this post and let us know more details.
  • Yes
  • No
0 voters
On a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, how do you like the new photogrammetry?
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
On a scale of 1-10, 10 being smoothest, how is your performance/stability in this update? Please vote once you have played the updated sim for at least an hour.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
Is your performance/stability worse, the same, or better than before the City Update? Please vote once you have played the updated sim for at least an hour.
  • Worse
  • The same
  • Better
0 voters
On a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, how would you globally rate this update? (This question will be used as a reference between each update)
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters
2 Likes

I would like to congratulate the development team and express my sincere appreciation for the wonderful photogrammetry areas and cities we have received. The imagery is breathtakingly sharp, clean, and detailed, and it is an absolute pleasure to fly over these areas. The visual quality is truly impressive.

However, I do have one critical observation. I would have been very happy to see the photogrammetry coverage extended beyond the cities themselves to include their wider surroundings as well — nearby villages, forests, fields, and other rural areas.

At the moment, this photogrammetry update appears to focus almost exclusively on the cities, while unfortunately the surrounding areas are not covered to the same extent.

For future updates, I would greatly appreciate it if the photogrammetry coverage could be expanded considerably beyond the city boundaries. Covering a much larger surrounding area would make flying across these regions feel far more seamless, natural, and immersive.

Once again, congratulations to the entire development team for the outstanding quality of the new photogrammetry. I sincerely hope that future updates can build upon this excellent work by providing broader photogrammetry coverage around the featured cities as well.

11 Likes

In which altitude do you fly, for a sharp, clean and detailed photogrammetry imagery…?

I found that a minimum of 1500 feet AGL gives a good balance between sharpness and being able to discern detail. It did take a bit of flying around to get the full detail loaded in for me.

Love the city update.

However, what annoys me the most with these trailers - They always appear better than they actually are! Although they came hoops and loops with improved detailed photogrammetry and you have my praise for that. But why trailers always appear more enhanced than the actual game?!

5 Likes

What settings did the team use for the promotion photo?

Maybe Ai setting…

Yeah definitely. After I read the announcement I did a flight to LICR (Reggio Calabria) and it didn’t look all that appealing. As if the textures aren’t fully loaded but I waited a bit and it remained the same. Is the marketing material made with some sort of supercomputer or enhanced with AI?

2 Likes

The new imagery looking fantastic on the PS5 Pro :slight_smile:

1 Like

Install process was a bit tedious, as I had to restart the sim in order for the update to become enabled. But that does not only affect the update, a recent scenery purchase showed the same behaviour

1 Like

Thanks devs, for this beautiful city update
As a fan for photogrammatry i would say cover the whole world with it
I think the techniques used for this update looks so subliminal that it is hard to find time to shut the pc down :star_struck:

7 Likes

First of all thanx for this update.

I live and fly in Sicily and it’s a huge mistery why they add Messina, Scilla and Reggio Calabria forgetting the two big pylons on both sides of Messina Straits (Torre Faro Sicily side and Torre Santa Trada Calabria side); any chance to add them in the future? thanx a lot

Pylons of Messina

2 Likes

Some random thoughts on this CU:

Overall, I consider that this is a very good CU - on the same level as WU21, CU15 & WU22 on my PC. I flew around all nine areas at ~ 1,000 ft in the Zlin Shock Ultra, spread over 8 hrs. The selection of the nine areas allowed my flights to cover two areas at a time:

  • Trieste & Urdine
  • Rimini & Pisa
  • Reggio & Calabria
  • Cagliari
  • Bolzano & Genoa

Making for some great flights.

In most areas, TIN trees were effectively masked by “regular” trees, though there were a few spots where they were, as in previous CUs, rather noticable.

Buildings were generally well represented. Some had that “melted” look (but not too badly), and others a slight greenish tinge, but not in sufficient numbers to detract from my flying experience.

Performance was good, with framerates in the 80’s and 90’s, except at Bolzano Airport, where they were exceptionally low - 'teens to 30s. This may be due to Bolzano being a bespoke airport (WU IX), surrounded by mountains & now with higher resolution TIN around it. The combination overwhelmed my standard bush-flying graphics settings:

Expand to see my graphics settings
Item Setting
Display Mode Full Screen
HDR10 On
Exposure Compensation EV-1
Full Screen Res 3840 x 2160
Anti-Aliasing TAA
Render scaling 100
AMD FidelityFX Sharpening 200
Max Frame Rate On
Max Frame Rate Value 60
Frame Generation AMD FSR 4.0
Framerate Multiplier 2x (N/A)
VSync Off (N/A)
VSync Interval Monitor refresh rate (N/A)
Dynamic Settings On
Frame Rate Target 40
- -
Global Rendering Quality Custom
Terrain LOD 400
Off Screen Terrain Pre-Cache Ultra
Displacement Mapping On
Buildings High
Trees Medium
Plants High
Rocks High
Grass High
Object LOD 200
Volumetric Clouds Ultra
Texture Resolution High
Anisotropic Filtering 16x
Water Waves High
Raytraced Shadows Off
Shadow Maps 2048
Terrain Shadows 512
Contact Shadows High
Windshield Effects Medium
Ambient Occulsion High
Cubemap Reflections 256
Raymarched Reflections Medium (reduces windshield reflections)
Light Shafts Ultra
Depth of Field Ultra
Motion Blur Off
Visual Particle Effects Quality High
Glass Cockpit Refresh Rate High
Characters Quantity Low
Characters Variety Ultra
Characters Quality Medium
Airport Services Quantity Low
Airport Service Variety Ultra
Parked Aircraft Quantity Low
Parked Aircraft Variety Ultra
Aircraft Traffic Quantity Low
Aircraft Traffic Variety Ultra
Road Traffic Ultra
Sea Traffic Off
Fauna Ultra
Seatbelt Visibility On

As soon as I left the vicinity of the airport, framerates started to increase. Leaving the TIN area they were back to the high 90s - low 100s, which is “standard” for my settings.

One minor TIN bug was noted at Rimini, reported here.

On the plus side, the port at Genoa looks really good at 1,000 ft, though if you go down close, you’ll notice there is a mixture of TIN and generic cranes that don’t quite match.

This high-resolution TIN does wonders for some pretty complex autostrada, and most of the time the AI traffic followed the elevated sections rather than dropping to ground level. I enjoyed following these roads & viewing the engineering that was required to create them IRL.

The photogrammetry looked really good on my 55" TV screen. I flew in real-time with live weather, so don’t know how these areas look in different seasons, though.

The main detratctor in the CU is simply that the areas covered are rather small. With the exception of Reggio & Calabria, which made for a great tour around the Strait, it did not take long to fly out of the covered areas, even with the low-n-slow Shock Ultra. Yes, I know these are “City” updates & they did indeed cover the cities, but a larger coverage area for each would be so much better! :slightly_smiling_face:

I haven’t had chance to check out the Italy World Update yet. I really need to get on that.

What are your PC specs?

First of all, I would like to thank you for your update on Italy. At first, I thought it covered the whole country, but unfortunately it only concerns certain parts of Italy.

I was a little disappointed with the representation of my city, Bari, in MSFS 2024 City updade IV is WRONG in ITALY - #12 by Symonx6. The city appears to have rivers, which is not only inaccurate but practically impossible, because Bari is located in a karst area where surface watercourses are very limited and many channels and “lame” are normally dry.

The seafront is also poorly represented, and several of the lighthouses and structures in the port are completely inaccurate and almost unrecognizable compared with the real ones.

I would therefore like to give the developers a suggestion for a future and more complete Italy update. To achieve a truly high-quality result, I believe it is important to carefully study every regional capital, paying particular attention to coastlines, seafronts, ports, mountainous areas, and locations containing important tourist landmarks.

Italy has an enormous variety of landscapes, architecture and geography, and many of these places are internationally famous tourist destinations. I am sure that some members of the development team have visited Italy and seen some of these important locations in person.

A more detailed study of the real geography and architecture of each area would make a future Italy update much more accurate and realistic.

2 Likes

I include them in my bug reports - click the linked Rimini TIN bug in my feedback. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

I’m liking CU16!

Yes, the Italy update is completely broken, and the scenery resembles the early stages of MSFS 2020. Flying over and sightseeing in Italy currently offers no satisfaction.
Neapol






Where did Pompeii go? This is some kind of tasteless joke.




I wonder what UNESCO would say about that.