Review: Dfflyer Direct Salt Lake City Pack (FS2020 & FS2024)

Test machine specs: MSI X670E, AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D, AMD Radeon RX 7900XTX, 48gb RAM

Review sim: FS2024

Dfflyer surprised almost everyone with their quality rendition of Detroit, particularly when it came to the complexity of its night-lighting. Salt Lake City is now the third city pack to follow Detroit (after Southeast Michigan Cities and Pittsburgh).

DETAIL

Those familiar with Dfflyer’s previous work will feel right at home with Salt Lake. The city’s primary buildings are very nicely modelled, although not quite to the standard we see with Orbx. I’d place the modelling about on a par with Drzewiecki, and a notch above Samscene. However some of the city’s more peripheral buildings really are quite low-res and blocky. Is this a problem? For the majority of people, no — because these structures are rarely going to be seen from lower than a few hundred feet. The main offenders are a church just outside the centre, and the Rice-Eccles Stadium, located some way from downtown.

The Utah State Capitol building and those surrounding it are the most impressive pieces of modelling here and it’s hard to find fault with them, save for a number of trees growing ‘through’ the Conference Center (see image 9 — hopefully this will get fixed).

As usual, this pack’s strength is its night-lighting — an area in which Dfflyer truly excels. In darkness, the city looks stunning in FS2024.

PERFORMANCE

Excellent for me, even with Pacsim’s KSLC airport installed.

VERDICT

Salt Lake City is another decent city pack in Dfflyer’s rapidly-expanding catalogue — however I can’t help but think this one was slightly rushed. There are elements that feel unfinished or neglected, such as the Conference Centre (with its leafy parasites) and the stadium. There’s also a logo on the Sheraton Hotel that’s back to front (see image 10). These relatively minor issues don’t really spoil the scenery but they undoubtedly give the impression that the usual due care and attention might not have been paid to this latest project.

That said, this pack greatly enhances the SLC area and the buildings mostly fit very well into the photogrammetry (a couple are not fully ‘anchored’ to the ground but I think this a sim limitation when it comes to uneven terrain). Add some sublime night-lighting and what you have is a very decent product, despite the shortcomings. For those wanting to acquire it in the coming days, the Dfflyer Direct website is currently offering it at half-price, using the discount code STILLHERE. When you’re only paying £3 ($4 or €3.50), the mild annoyances are easily forgiven.

IMAGES










Hey @JakTrax78, I recently stumbled upon your reviews of my city packs and want to thank you for taking the time write them. I really enjoyed reading them and can’t say I disagree with anything you’ve said. You have a strong attention to detail and honest assessment in my opinion. Flight sim has been a big part of my life since 2006, but scenery development is a new chapter for me and each city I’ve developed so far has played a special part in my life; it means a lot to me seeing fellow simmers like yourself excited about exploring and sharing them with the community.

You are right this one was a bit rushed. I’d been sitting on it at 90% completion for awhile while life got in the way of flight sim. Sales really slow down between releases and I’ve got a long backlog of additional cities and a few airports I’m trying to get out, so one weekend I decided to do all I could do for SLC and then ship it. Not an excuse, but a reality I’ll have to fight against to keep quality up. I’ll be sure to address the areas you mentioned in an update later this year.

Lastly, if you’re willing, I’d love to have you as a beta tester for all future packs. It’s difficult to see clearly by the time I finish a city, so a second set of eyes would be really helpful prior to release and help keep me accountable the quality I want to achieve. If you’re interested, feel free to send me a DM on Discord and happy flying. :slight_smile: