Xbox Series X review: MK-Studios Dublin EIDW v2

Aircraft used: default 781, LVFR 320, AT7
Live weather: on

DETAIL

I can’t speak about v1 of this airport (it was only ever available for PC) but v2 has for me established MK-Studios as one of the top 10 devs for MSFS. The detail on offer here is superb and it’s for the moment got to be their flagship product.

The terminal areas are very well done and two piers feature internal modelling — which has unfortunately been toned down a little from the PC original — however I do mean ‘toned down’ rather than ‘stripped’. It all still looks very good, especially from a pilot’s vantage point, but there are no passengers. The custom Aer Lingus jetways look amazing, I have to say. What could be more Irish than adding as much green paint to the terminal as you can?! What’s great to see is some very decent landside modelling, including roads (with accurate markings), car-parks, the bus station, hotels, a petrol station, a McDonald’s restaurant, plus more. The church — a prominent and unusual feature of EIDW’s central area — has been modelled, complete with detailed clock tower.

Moving airside, the clutter is plentiful — much of it custom — but the ground textures don’t quite live up to the standard of the terminals. They’re far from bad; just not what I expected. Maybe it’s the way the real place is? Thankfully the apron, taxiway and runway markings are all very good. The new runway looks pristine but that’s to be expected, given its age. The glass panels round by the commuter ramp have been done, although they look a bit strange from a distance. The red/white blast screen adjacent to the Aer Lingus long-haul pier is included too.

MK have given the perimeter some attention, including a few warehouses on the southern perimeter road, plus some bits and pieces to the east of the terminals, near the motorway.

PERFORMANCE

Not bad; probably the good side of average for an airport of this size and complexity. I’ve managed many successful flights with various aircraft, using both the drone and exterior cams, but you need to be a bit careful. The drone seems to trouble it more than exterior viewing but both will eventually cause black screens (which sometimes return). CTDs are somewhat rarer but do occur. I’ve encountered very little stuttering; it runs smoothly.

I prefer to use EIDW with live weather off, to try and conserve valuable memory.

VERDICT

I had to have EIDW for my UK/Ireland ATR ops but it’s an airport I can recommend to those with nothing more than a casual interest in the place. The detail is very good and stability is about what I expected (perhaps a little better). There are many quite unique routes one can fly out of EIDW since it’s one of Europe’s westernmost hubs (along with LIS and KEF).

I got it at a discount on release but it’s not bad value at £15-£16. For an immersion boost, I recommend adding Orbx’s Dublin City pack, since the airport is quite close to the city centre. Runway 34 is only really used when there’s a strong northerly crosswind blowing across the two parallels but it does allow for scenic approaches over the city and port.

IMAGES

![Microsoft Flight Simulator-2023_10_27-02-27-17|690x388]
(upload://fySj71imIIznE1E2TjN60LjvzdJ.jpeg)

Not sure what the significance of this little fella is?

5 Likes

Screenshots added.

The recent update has added the previously missing Eirecell 732 (used for training) to the cargo apron. Stability seems improved too.

1 Like

First flight into EIDW (MK-Studios) the C310R BS’ed on the runway with live weather off. A sale purchase so not too stingy, but not so great either.

I think SU14 is the culprit. I’ve noticed some very stable airports under SU13 are no longer performing under 14.

EIDW wasn’t great upon release, then SU13 and an MK update seemed to fix it. Then along came the SU14 wrecking ball…

2 Likes

Yeah I’ll buy that! It has been an uneven ride since Su13. I have been staying out of those threads/conversations, but I have experienced mixed results. Taking the ostrich approach till the next Su rolls around and keeping my head down when it comes to Su. At least with add-ons we have some ability to choose and share solutions!

First flight out of Dublin, second overall, was BS/CTD free in the Carenado C182RG-II. Will have to plan a Ryanair departure in the PMDG 737/8 soon. Cheers!

Ryanair departure in the -700 was BS/CTD free with live weather on. A first for me: A warning bell sounds when the Jetway moves!

EIDW v2 on xbox X. Performance is not too bad for me with the PMDG 737 700, I do find if I fly too EIDW I can park up (as long as I don’t view outside the cockpit) without any black screen. If I fly from EIDW to another 3rd party airfield I do black screen on landing. With EIDW there are object files missing and sometimes some terminals don’t appear until very close proximity. EIDW after update none of the stand guidance systems have poles they all hover in the air with no poles, I have installed many times so I gather they are missing in the files downloaded. I hope this will be corrected next update.

PIREP after latest update: 738 no BS on arrival with live weather and was able to drone around.

2 Likes

Can I just ask On Xbox X - EIDW v2 after update (and before) All the poles on the advanced parking indicators are missing. Just want to know if its me and a memory problem or its the same for all xbox users.

Yes, just noticed this too.

1 Like