ATC Window is More Frustrating

For the life of me why would you take a step backwards with the UI?

Often, the ATC window will have a significant number of available choices. These choices in 2020 are all visible along with their associated choice number.

With this new UI you can only see four choices and must use an awkward scroll bar to scroll down the list. I have tried to use the edges to drag the window size downward vertically, but I have been unable to get a window size cursor to appear. I have only been able to get the horizontal resize cursor to show when I place the mouse pretty far to the left or the right of the left or right window edges, but making the window wider isn’t the issue.

This makes absolutely no sense. Who was put in charge of this, the intern?

19 Likes

Lots of us said that during the Alpha and I gues they never changed it. So much for listening to community feedback I gues

6 Likes

After the servers have cooled off, this is my biggest issue with FS2024 right now. But I’m sure I’ll discover something worse in the next few days lol
I should add that the key I use to open the ATC window won’t close it??? I have to manually click it with the mouse. Annoying and awkward.

4 Likes

Funny enough, mine too! I guess they did a good job if this is our worst!

Change the binding to “Open Communications Panel” that will toggle.

:slight_smile:

1 Like

See:

Revise ATC Window to Show ALL Available Selections - Official Microsoft Flight Simulator / Wishlist - Microsoft Flight Simulator Forums

2 Likes

Agree @NixonRedgrave . I was just thinking the same tonight. Also, the most recent dialog I get from atc is often hidden too, so I have to use the upper scroll bar to scroll down to see it. But that isn’t sticky so next atc command come in and I need more scrolling down to see it again.

Window should be scalable, but isn’t as far as I can tell. I also used the toggle ATC (assigned to a hotas button) in fs2020, and can concur that there is only an option to open ATC dialog window in FS2024 but not close it again, which is a bit annoying.

4 Likes

I don’t have MSFS 2024 yet because I ordered the Limited Collectors Edition. But wow, that’s a terrible user experience!

In 2020, I keep my ATC window resized from top to bottom so I can see all options at once.

I voted for your Wishlist topic, as well as the bug report for it.

1 Like

Yeah, I found myself scrolling up and down continuously thinking that I might miss my airport when it made the ‘Closer to me’ list.

Maybe the people at Beyond ATC or SayIntentions slipped someone on the team a few bucks under the table. :wink:

2 Likes

I also noticed you can assign a key or button to open the ATC windows but you can only close it using the mouse. So it is not a toggle. Unhandy as I try to avoid using keyboard and/or mouse.

1 Like

Switch to “Open Communications Panel” it works as a toggle.

3 Likes

I’m getting crazy with the key bindings. Thanks!

2 Likes

In addition to fixing this pretty huge issue, I would like to add a request for an input field that could be used to filter the airports in range by their call letters. Meaning you can choose to see only what is relevant to you for your flight.

4 Likes

Welcome to the forums, FishBump9545. Feature requests are handled in the Official Microsoft Flight Simulator > Wishlist section.

There is a Wishlist topic for this. Voting for it (at the top of the topic) will signal your interest:

Understood. Thank you, Kindly.

1 Like

atc window still super idiot, not scrolling down properly on new communications. so bad. disaster game

2 Likes

SU 1 and atc scrolling is still not fixed

how possible i have to manually scroll down every message i receive


2 Likes

I re-activate this thread as it"s getting very frustrated updates after updates.

  1. The proposed list of choice is not resizeable. When it’s the closest airfieldit’s even worst as the list is dynamic and you may click on wrong choice.
  2. For the closest airfield list choice, the list is full of helicopter pad when flying in urban area. You spend seconds clickling on farther / closer airfield searching miserably in the list for your airport. Would love to have a filter feature. Searchable could also be a nice-to-have: Searchable "Nearest Airports" List In ATC Window
  3. The window doesn’t support to get move to a second monitor without being totally unreadable (wrong font size, no button
) and you have to fine tune it again and again. Putting a second window and make it active (interact with it) creates a 5 to 10 ftps loss.
  4. Sometimes you loose shortcut. Pressing 1, 2, 3
 works then few minutes later you have to interact with the mouse. And it could get back to normal later.

This status in SU2 but also in SU3 1.5.15 ;(

3 Likes

My biggest wish is for the ATC window to be able to be moved to a secondary monitor.
But yeah, all the things mentioned are also a big regression from FS2020.

1 Like

Agree, for me it’s the single most annoying aspect of 2024 and that’s saying something.

The sizing is linked to the overall UI sizing options which don’t allow you to go below 18 I think, this was the same in 2020 until it was resolved in an update.

The ability to filter out helipads if you’re flying a plank wing and vice versa is important.

Also there need to be more selectable lines in the dialogue box.

1 Like

There has been zero changes in this regard (UI), but also some new issues (AI assistance entering infinite loops for example, among others) regarding ATC