Given the affordable prices of a 2TB SSD, even at the cost of keeping the PC on for a week, if it were possible I would download the whole package ![]()
In the past, when there was no fibre optic and we had copper ADSL lines, a 15gb game, for example, could take hours, so why wouldn’t I be able to download 1.3TB in the same hours? Yes, the size changes, but the internet infrastructure has also changed as has the storage space.
Downloading those 1.3tb on a gigabit line would take less than 5 hours, perfectly acceptable for me if they give me the option if it means I can avoid blurry textures, etc…
Don’t ask me, I’m simply stating what I believe Seb said.
I agree, if that option is available then I might decide to buy FS2024.
They said that they will allow downloading like 2020 but will discourage against downloading the entire sim because it’s 1.3TB because:
-It could take 25 hours to do so depending on connection.
-Updates will take a long time vs streaming some content where updates can be done server side.
-It will take up alot of space.
In the next few weeks they will likely break down how the downloading will segmented. This will be especially useful for Xbox players who might only want to download planes and airports rather than entire regions.
You can already see how - it’s basically going to work through the “my library” section of the marketplace (former package manager).
You can select and/or expanded packages there and set them to disable/install/stream these individually using “more options” - it just seems the related functionality is disabled, so that options menu is basically currently useless.
I like to think of this in two distinct problem categories:
- A) Do you want to modify content?
- B) Do you want to make the game fast, stutter free and “reliable”.
I think everybody wants B) … and some want A) on top of that.
For A) there is no other way then to get a readable set of files onto a local drive … and then be able to “layer” it on top of all the “default” content that comes from the system.
“If” the local caching strategy is “solid” then some “dependency and time aware most recently used” (layered?) caching would solve B) without any need for manual intervention.
Using the “install” option is basically a manual caching instruction saying “Use dedicated local caching space for the data of this group … and do not apply the normal no-longer-needed deletion logic of the Rolling Cache”.
As with all caching solution, they never are perfect but hopefully “good enough”. Right now it is far from “good enough” … this is easy to see … but there is no reason why a manual download of TB of data which I will never actually need should give better results then streaming plus a really sophisticated caching implementation.
Asobo will find a way. But it will take time and a few updates.
PS: I started to dig a little into the Rolling Cache and for example with the Marketplace it is very obvious that there is a lot of room for improvement:
This!
I wonder if LODs are “fixed” or static across the board. Or if they are dynamic, adjusted in real time based on download speed and other performance variables.
I wonder if we will need to wait for the marketplace to open until we get these options, to me I don’t see why we need to wait for that to get the choice to download packages that are already available to stream.
Wouldn’t that require them to shut down the servers in order to update the game?
I would rather have the game made available offline than streaming seeing how bad it as atm…
I have yet to watch the stream … but already now in FS2024 we can see the “Installed” category. So the difference between the 3 “universes” is just for how many packages I will/did select the “install” option.
I like to think of the “Installed” packages as … “permanently cached by user request”.
However, what I am missing is the “Data Settings” option called:
- “Update installed packages automatically shortly prior to usage”
- … some form of update via streaming
To some degree this is already happening. If you look at the streamed aircraft in FS2024, they do not only put information into the Rolling Cache, but they also write some files to your disk (e.g. the sound packages).
So even that hybrid approach already exists today (to some degree).
I think (hope) the answer is … No.
However, there are different aspects to what you call … “the game”.
- The client … FS2024.exe
- The backend (servers) … providing APIs to access
- The databases … with the “dynamic” game data
- The static data sources … with the “static” game data
Even in FS2020 they forced you to update to a new sim.exe version prior to launch. So at any point they only need to keep two versions of backend API alive … the latest … the previous.
So, they already used rolling updates on the server side. Basically a constant “migration” with backward compatibility.
The updates which @Bossman7126 mentioned are more the “The static data sources” … like new aircraft, new 3D meshes, new trees, new sat images etc.
If done properly all the backend updates can happen without any downtime. And FS2020 already has acted this way.
However, FS2024 is trying to reduce (remove?) the need to “install” anything (manually) on your system in cases where they roll out new data for a new region. I assume that this will require so more advanced versioning on the different asset types … and better and more robust data validation to avoid those nasty crashes which seem to be common if there are some ID conflicts, or variable name mismatches etc.
So in short … I guess FS2024 needs (has) more sophisticated asset dependency handling.
Makes sense
Don’t forget there is dynamic lod if you have that enabled. I think for testing it should be disabled because it’s hard to know what’s popping due to streaming.
While I don’t think we have to wait for the MP I think the options are gone for either compatibility reasons (as they may have had some hard code side connections to the market place module) or they simply were part of the market place module.
Either way it was told that the “disable” function will be available on the upcoming patch, so maybe chances are we’ll also get a way to keep packages locally after that patch.
Downloading will launch before the marketplace.
Unless the feature has been rolled out and works flawlessly, it’s unlikely that 3rd party developers will be able to successfully integrate their products into 2024.
I’m sorry, but who thinks this “entire sim” is only 1.3TB?
I don’t think there is any ambiguity… MSFS2024 will not run without a secure and reliable internet connection with a suitable bandwidth capability (100Mbs?)
I’m not convinced that the local cache is of any real benefit.
I am trying to quantify that in a different thread:
Right now it is a mixed story … but the RollingCache.ccc in some cases will provide 80% or more of all the data that is needed.
So while I do (already) see a lot of benefit it, on the other hand, it is correct that a fully “offline” game play with FS2024 is not possible. At least during the launch phase of the game and a flight server access is needed for sure.