[PS5] Can we talk about how realistic this sim is? (Warning: long post!)

yeah, i concur fully, i have to admit that i dont use pro gear, i mean, i wish i could, honestly, but this is how it is

the pmdg 737 is indeed, no1 on my list as to how well it captures that seat of the pants feeling im talking about. The first time in my life that i pulled a yoke and the wheels were off the runway i will never forget it, it felt like, slickery, oily… like riding over cotton balls…. while in the sim a lot of planes feel like riding over saw tooth and they are made of paper and fly on rails. There’s a certain, hard to point, randomness in movement to the whole thing that’s missing or is insufficient. Or maybe they are trying to simulate it when it can’t be simulated, and you should hard code it into the thing.

Now that is something the consumer-grade flight sim market has also recently been evolving in. We’re talking force feedback gear here which used to be something only heard of on professional grade simulators. “Feeling the wind” on your yoke if you’re flying the real thing is something a simmer has never encountered before. While it can be overwhelming if one was to theoretically find himself in this hypothetical situation of suddenly being in the position where you have to fly a real aircraft mid-flight and land it, if they remain calm and apply the best to their knowledge, chances are significant disaster will be prevented. Also another point to add, how silly it sounds for many sounds logical to the ones who know it: Bigger airplanes are easier to fly. They are inherently more stable than smaller aircraft, and commercial jet planes are much comfier for the pilots aswell, the stick won’t be as intimidating, rather smooth.

There are multiple affordable options for FFB gear, quite easy to find. If you ever find yourself able to spare some money for a better PC and gear: Do it. It’s not as expensive as many think. (However RAM prices are kind of an issue atm) But nonetheless it’s absolutely worth it. I find myself flying 10 hours a day sometimes :rofl: I just search up on the website of the livery i’m flying what real lines they fly and just do the exact same flight. I once flown in a real 737 moving simulator and immediately felt at home. I might still become a real 737 pilot through modular training, really sparks my interest.

All this to say, consumer-grade simulation has nowadays become a serious option for autodidacts who wish to step in to pilot license training with confidence. The market is now certainly evolving, with expo’s and event like the FlightSimWeekend in Lelystad only being a couple of weeks from now where many companies and enthousiasts gather to share ideas and try out new software and hardware for Flight Sim. WinCTRL for example have excellent products for both Boeing and Airbus which are very, very affordable. BeyondATC even has realistic ATC with AI voices from the local area you’re flying, and sometimes they aren’t even very understandable due to accents, which is a common thing in some parts of the world. This all adds to your knowledge, expanding yourself.

I have my PPL and I fly a C172. And using a some proper peripherals, it’s pretty 1:1 handling wise. I don’t understand what you’re on about stating it’s “absurd”

well its possible we are looking at different things, i’ll give you an example of what i mean, in the sim, if you put some effort into it, you can pull the 172 from the runway into a straight vertical. I dont think that’s going to happen in real life with 160hp at the front

Out-of-envelope flight is incredibly difficult to simulate and will likely never be achievable without supercomputers running high fidelity CFD.

If you fly normally, the flight model is incredibly good. Like @Pieter2427 said, the C172 flies very similarly to the real thing (as well as a computer program can do, at least).

i get what you mean, and i could agree with that, matter of fact, i think in many cases the a/c flight performance is pretty good… meaning,how they climb, how the ydive, how they crab… they are all close enough in my opinion

my beef is with how they feel on the stick, way too light, reminds me of my rc plane rather than ther eal thing…, maybe a better example of what i mean is this, fly straight and level on the CTSL (on 2024) and drop the flaps, see how the aircraft shoots skyward instantly like it was made out of balsa wood.. that’s room for improvement right there… the ctsl is light, i get it, but still, i believe there’s something going on mass-wise and inertia-wise that need some fine tuning

MSFS doesn’t have native force feedback. But Moza does a pretty good job simulating the pressure on the control surfaces. Again, feels pretty much like the real thing.

When I fly the DA-62 IRL and dump the flaps it also jumps quite a bit. Never flew a CTSL, so couldn’t comment on that, but I know in the more aerodynamic models, there’s definitely jumping.

I’m a retired public safety specialist and ran a 20-year self-defense / lethal force training company. “Dry practice” at home is essential—it builds the fine motor skills and techniques to make things work under pressure. “My training kicked in”.

I used to tell my students: you’ve done it behind the console long enough—now come feel it for real! Anything involving real risk—death or serious injury—has to be validated in the real world.
Real physics. Real stress. Real consequences. Feel that?
When your stomach drops, When your knees get weak, When you realize this might actually hurt you…and that surge of adrenaline—that’s real life!

A sim doesn’t even come close. It’s a great tool—but it’s not the real thing.

i can relate, a few years back i used to tune motorcycle engines, and we said the same about the dyno… its different out on the road or the track with real bugs on your visor, yu were running cool, but now, you are running hot.. what happened’? reality happened

i have to admit that i don’t use pro gear, maybe that’s what i’m missing, could be, it is on my pending list no doubt

Gear does make a difference. Even if it’s not FFB, reasonably strong springs do a halfway decent job preventing you from rapidly moving the controls to the stops. And longer throw distance also makes fine movement easier.

I flew the Ikarus C42 for a couple of years, if your in flap speed and just deploy the flaps you shoot skywards, you need to apply a good forward push on the elevator to keep straight and level when deploying a stage of flaps. If you were faster than flap speed and the flaps did not rip off - quite possible in the sim then you would instantly shoot up, so depending on the aircraft this type of feature seems well modelled.

As said above keep within the flight envelope and a number of aircraft perform very true to real life.

I have been flying the C172 a lot lately.

I have exactly zero hours in any real plane. All I am going off of is how I think the plane should fly based on my basic understanding of physics and observations of lots of people posting videos of actual flying.

With linear axes on my controllers, the C172 feels way too light and snappy. The rudder will yaw the plane very quickly, almost instantaneous, and feels like it’s on rails with minimal inertial mass. The pitch and roll throw distance that Charlie Fox referenced seems way too small on my setup. Very minimal movements have outsized influence on the plane, in my uninformed opinion.

What I have not done yet is spend the time scaling back sensitivities in the controller axes to find something “better” for me. This is probably the only real variable I have to adjust.

I generally lower the sensitivity on all axes, especially toward the center of the axis.

I have flown a C172 a handful of times, but not enough to have a muscle memory of exactly how it feels. But I lower the sensitivity for all axes to -50 and them impose a .01 dead zone at the extremities and this feels more accurate. It’s definitely less twitchy. Linear is way too twitchy.

I’ve logged around 200 hours in GA aircraft (Cessna, Grumman Cheetah, Saab Safir, Zephyr, Piper Cherokee).

I’m not sure how rough a landing has to be before it would be considered a “crash” in the real world, but in my experience the flight dynamics for similar aircraft in MSFS are actually quite good.

You don’t fully get the real-life feel in the flare (like subtle ballooning effects), but overall the behavior is fairly convincing.

As for airliners, I don’t have enough real-world experience to comment.

All peripheral dependent.

MSFS (going back to even FSX.. with properly tuned flight model parameters.. especially A2A type flight dynamics “overlays”), is extraordinarily accurate (inside of normal operations envelope).

The relationships between pitch/power/roll/yaw are spot on. You could find differences in behavior twixt two real world C172s, greater than that between any real C172 and she sim itself.

Of course, hardware (yoke/pedals/quadrant, etc.) makes a huge difference too.

Do you mean dependent on the physical throw distance of the peripheral, specifically? That would make sense to me.

Yes. A small controller stick is really hard to move with some finesse. A force feedback joystick with a 30 cm extension has a lot more throw.

Consider not only the distance, but how much effort it would take to move a PA-28 yoke from stop to stop (in pitch) with all the airflow resisting control deflections at even a moderate speed.

Non-FFB yokes vary, but mine is about 75%-80% on the throw distance compared to the real thing. I’ve not measured the force, and again, it’ll vary depending on speed (and even trim), but it feels fairly close to the 80-90 knot range in pitch but closer to slow flight resistance in roll.

Whereas a game controller can go stop to stop nearly instantaneously with very little effort. That, the lack of kinesthetic sense, and using outside view is why you see people bouncing all over the sky. That said, some folks manage to get it down pretty well, but the difference is still pretty stark.