[PS5] Can we talk about how realistic this sim is? (Warning: long post!)

Have you been secretly watching me?

A brief skim read of this thread tells me I shouldn’t be posting but it’s late and I’ve had 2 special cups of tea.

It’d take a pilot to answer the question and they’d say no it’s not realistic yet it does allow you to learn the controls.

Much like a motorcycle racing simulator, but until you feel the physics it can never be claimed as realistic. That being said I do think that should the worse happen and I’m the only one in an airliner that puts their hand up I reckon I could at least make radio contact, follow instructions and know what each control did and where it was.

I give me and the passengers a 50-50 chance of survival possible better if it’s a Cat III on an A320 or similar. Max autobrake naturally.

Rotorcraft… well we’re doomed. Those things are tricksie.

Those are default aircraft you are using. The ones that come with the sim will never be realistic or true to real life flying. If you want '“study-level” or realistic flying operations, you will need to drop some money to get these 3rd aircraft add-ons that simulate it. From a real world pilot myself here, no sim will ever get it perfect but it can get close to it. MSFS is capable of achieving that realism, just not with the default aircraft.

PMDG does this well, A2A, Fenix, Flightsim Labs, etc., the only issue is since your on PS5, you are limited to PMDG, IniBuilds, and so on here. Fenix and FlightSim Labs as well as many 3rd party developers are PC only as they run extenally to produce the flight model and systems it needs to make it realistic. Same thing with A2A such as their Commanche and such.

I play X-plane 12 and Little navmap on the Mac. *Arguably gives a better experience of a simulator than MSFS on any platform.

Went to MSFS for the world detail with its more gaming experience.

I’m treading lightly here as Flight Simulator people appear to be rightly serious about their games. For me these sims offer a great insight into cockpit layouts and flight procedures. Dare say that should I wish to get a private pilot’s license I’d be familiarising myself with said layouts etc.

*from what I’ve read.

If we’re talking default aircraft here then yes, XP12 does a better job. However, if we’re talking premium addons like PMDG, then no, XP12 wouldn’t be particularly “better”.

Well, X-Plane and MSFS are both games and do not pretend to be anything but games.

We worked with Boeing on a 737 training tool based on our commercial version of that aircraft, but it was created only for the professional version of MSFS. That is a very different platform and is available only to professional customers. I believe X-Plane also has professional versions.

Mathijs Kok
PMDG

Thanks for the reply.