FSLTL or FS Traffic?

I don’t understand your defensive (aggressive?) reply. I’m glad your installation was smooth as silk, but mine wasn’t. None of your proposed situations are the case. I read the instructions, have the latest versions of everything (AIG self updates), and I did a multi-region installation. I’m not the only one who has had installation problems. Just Google the issue and you find forum entries like, “AIG OCI Traffic Installer Stuck on Particular Download,” and, “AIG Manager crashing during airline installation” among many.

Also, I didn’t even list all of the difficulties I had. For example, AIG Manager just wouldn’t accept the first directory I entered for the data download, and kept telling me I needed to do setup again. When I changed to a different directory, all was well and it was fine (and, anticipating the question, none were sim directories). Same thing with online account registration. The first two times it didn’t recognize it, the third time it did. Who knows why?

And I’m definitely not a paid shill of, what exactly? A freeware program trying to smear another freeware program (huh?!?).

As for performance, I’m not sure what to tell you or what our respective machine stats are, but I’m definitely seeing significant slowdowns at the gates vs other injectors. Granted, I’ve only tried this for the last 24 hrs at large airports (BOS, LAX, LGA, DEN, JFK, MIA, etc) and maybe there’s no slowdown at all at, say, Cleveland or San Diego. Haven’t tried those yet. There was some slowdown in Tel Aviv, though, which isn’t huge. And, again, my FPS even at the gates was still fine and acceptable, it wasn’t unplayable. It could be that,you, being in VR, have already taken the majority of your performance hit with the VR itself and the addition of the injector isn’t changing much. I’ll continue testing.

And my overall impression was very positive. I said, “it’s currently impressive and far better than FS Traffic as an offline option.” Models are great, lighting is great. And unlike FS Traffic (where nothing seems to ever happen) and FSLTL (which, as their manual states, can have a significant time lag to where new air or ground traffic movement is captured by the injector on-screen) the action seen in AIG is immediate. And I was complimentary of the landing FPS performance at 100% AIG traffic volume vs the same performance in FSLTL with significant ILS traffic and gate population setting restrictions.

I think I will use AIG a lot, but I don’t feel it’s as easy an installation as the FBW installer for FSLTL or as straightforward to manage as FSLTL’s in-game menu bar extension. I don’t see that as me hating on AIG or it being product assassination.

To bring AIG into the mix… what runs best FSTL or FStraffic or AIG

FSTL is quite heavy on CPU - I’d imagine they all are but out of interest does anyone knows what is least CPU intensive?

I believe AIG updater recently and I’ve heard great things about it

I agree with you that FSTraffic doesn’t actually appear to be doing anything, I’m in the process of trying to get a refund for it.

I do not agree that AIG is far far harder to install or manage, you literally configure it and hit GO. A friend of mine installed it today on my recommendation, no problems whatsoever on his pretty mid range machine (2070 Super).

There’s just no way it’s fair to say it’s harder to install or manage.

Seems to me that AIG installer is very easy, but incredibly slow. Set it off then go do something else then come back an hour or two later.

Yes, the mechanisms of the installer are easy, but it was frequently freezing at certain airlines or models for me and I’d have to force close it and reopen and it would resume then… for hours. It was also crashing for me frequently. Again, restarting and continuing downloading worked.

By contrast, though, downloading another user’s full install took, like, 3 minutes. It’s a sloooooow installer…

Another thing, though, is you have to turn off manual prompts and select freeware only to make it easy. Otherwise it asks you every 5 seconds if there is a particular model you want to download or buy…

I probably selected the freeware only checkbox years ago, because it was pre-selected for me this time.

I recall the install being more complicated in years gone by, but mostly the problem was that it wasn’t clear to me what was going on. The prompts assume you’re familiar with the product.

Would be helpfull if you can report with Log files of those crashes in the official AIG FOrum so we can investigate and fix them.

Sure, happy to do so. I presume the logs are in the main directory?

yes they are all starting with Log_***

How is the situation now in December 2023? I just uninstalled AIG due to massive perf hit. Much worse than FSLT.

Is FS Traffic more optimized today? Cargo?

I’ve kind of given up on FS Traffic. The FPS was better but I was getting stuttering that was only happening with it installed. AIG is very impressive but it’s performance hit was very uneven. At times, it was terrific, and at other times (especially taxiing around big airport terminals) the hit was huge.

FSLTL seems to be the best option for now until BeyondATC arrives and takes the injection out of the sim, with hopefully little to no FPS hit.

I will simply use FSLTL with low traffic then. I am mainly after having some liveries at the gates.
It is mostly the arrival that takes the big hit.

Apparently it just got updated and easyjetsimpilot is very impresed :slight_smile:

FS Traffic models only and let FSLTL handle the injection.

That’s the combo I’ve been using, although with the new FSLTL model update, maybe I’ll give it a try again…

is fsltl became too heavy on performance after su14? i cannot keep it enabled at 3rd party airports without making the whole scene a stutter fest and flooding the vram

I might try simple traffic to keep the performance under control

Yes, it is extracting a much higher FPS penalty for me in SU 14 than it was before, although for me SU14 itself is a poor performer.

I bought FS Traffic a couple of days ago and my impression are very positive so far, great fps performance as well, no stuttering problem whatsoever for me.

Can anyone say which one uses less vram?

Do you have to use FSLTL to see contrails above you, or is there another method.

thanks

You should see contrails of any plane of sufficient altitude, above or below you, regardless of how it’s injected into the sim.