SU10 now coming in August

We have read every single post in that thread. Stability and performance on all our platforms, including Xbox Series X|S, is something the dev team takes very seriously. If you have watched any of the previous Dev Q&A sessions with Jorg, Seb, and Martial (either live on Twitch or the replays uploaded to YouTube), then you will know that this is something they have acknowledged is an issue and are actively working to improve. We don’t have any specific information beyond that to share at the moment, but you can be assured we will pass on more details to you as soon as we can.

As a reminder, our forum Code of Conduct states the following:

If you don’t see us responding, it isn’t because we are ignoring you. Sometimes we don’t have a good answer, or we are looking for an answer or we cannot comment on the issue at the time.

If a tree falls in the forest with nobody around, does it make a sound?

Mmm hmm right…:yawning_face:

First, I’m sure we all appreciate you replying to this thread and addressing some concerns. It’s rare we ever get anyone posting in any official capacity in a thread that isn’t an “official” thread started by the CM team in the first place.

It’s not so simple as “fix 3 bugs” like @BigCow74 said, although I get what he meant. But we’d love to see stuff from that bug list actually get addressed. In most cases, bugs are scheduled for a particular update, and keep getting pushed back to a future update. That update comes, and the bugs are pushed back again. All we want is these major outstanding issues to be dealt with.

In the Q&A earlier this year when they talked about SU8, they made a huge deal about their plan of making it a 100% bug fix update to “pay off the bug debt” (Jörg’s words) that they had accrued. There was supposed to be no new features (they stressed that heavily), and they were going to take care of some of the long standing bugs on the public bug list. People were understandably ecstatic about that announcement and looking forward to this update despite the fact it wouldn’t have new content or features.

What we got was a bunch of fixes for minor bugs no one was even aware were in the sim, none of the major ones that have been there since launch (or before) touched, new features added, and new bugs introduced that were identified on Day 1 of the SU8 beta, but not fixed for SU8 release.

And of course, SU9 was supposed to be stability fixes with no new features. We got new features, performance degradation, increased stuttering, and likely the least stable build since pre-SU5. So bad that XBox users are still suffering from its effects and can’t reliably use the software without CTD when it was stable prior to that update. And same for PC. The last time I encoutered this many crashes was prior to SU5. Many VR users have had their performance degraded to the point the sim is unusable in VR now. Again, bugs that were identified early in the beta were allowed to be released with the final build.

That’s what people are upset about. There’s not a lot of communication to the community that isn’t related to marketing. And what is communicated in the Q&As in terms of the road map and what actually happens seems to be 2 very different things.

There is a lot to unpack here so I’ll do the best I can in line with what you wrote. Let me start by saying thank you for the constructive and well thought out reply.

First, I’m sure we all appreciate you replying to this thread and addressing some concerns. It’s rare we ever get anyone posting in any official capacity in a thread that isn’t an “official” thread started by the CM team in the first place.

You’re not the first person to voice this and it something I take to heart. Specifically, on this note the team will be working to be better in our communication outward in threads when we can. As SeedyL pointed out, there are sometimes we just can’t share anything, or don’t have an answer in that moment. In that case I still believe we can work to at the very least acknowledge those points

It’s not so simple as “fix 3 bugs” like @BigCow74 said, although I get what he meant. But we’d love to see stuff from that bug list actually get addressed. In most cases, bugs are scheduled for a particular update, and keep getting pushed back to a future update. That update comes, and the bugs are pushed back again. All we want is these major outstanding issues to be dealt with.

Totally understand this point as noted when BigCow74 mentioned. I don’t fix bugs so lets just get that out there first. I say that to say I can’t tell you that it is easy or not easy to fix x-major bug. What I can tell you is that from this conversation and previous ones on this forum and others it is consistently reported to the team that there are static issues the community would like to see responded too. They are working hard on a lot of things behind the scenes and a variety of fixes is one of those things. It is not lost that what you said is high concern of the community and something myself and the team will continue to push

In the Q&A earlier this year when they talked about SU8, they made a huge deal about their plan of making it a 100% bug fix update to “pay off the bug debt” (Jörg’s words) that they had accrued. There was supposed to be no new features (they stressed that heavily), and they were going to take care of some of the long standing bugs on the public bug list. People were understandably ecstatic about that announcement and looking forward to this update despite the fact it would have new content or features.

What we got was a bunch of fixes for minor bugs no one was even aware were in the sim, none of the major ones that have been there since launch (or before) touched, new features added, and new bugs introduced that were identified on Day 1 of the SU8 beta, but not fixed for SU8 release.

And of course, SU9 was supposed to be stability fixes with no new features. We got new features, performance degradation, increased stuttering, and likely the least stable build since pre-SU5. So bad that XBox users are still suffering from its effects and can’t reliably use the software without CTD when it was stable prior to that update. And same for PC. The last time I encountered this many crashes was prior to SU5. Many VR users have had their performance degraded to the point the sim is unusable in VR now. Again, bugs that were identified early in the beta were allowed to be released with the final build.

This is a much broader subject in terms of changes and additions to updates. I could chime in here regarding work cycles and the perception around when things are added, but I’ve said that I am fairly sure a few times in this thread. With that said this is a good conversation reminder for me to the team about expectation setting and reminding of past instances

That’s what people are upset about. There’s not a lot of communication to the community that isn’t related to marketing. And what is communicated in the Q&As in terms of the road map and what actually happens seems to be 2 very different things.

That is fair. Expectations are key. We just spoke about this yesterday in a sync about how we communicate going forward. I do believe that a lot of the heartache in the community could be addressed if communicated differently. This is something we will continue to work on and learn from as a team.

Really appreciate this conversation Crunchmeister71 wish I had more context for you at this moment, but rest assured when I do you, and the rest of the community will have it as well.

Who is on that team you keep referring to? For the most part I think the forum team is doing a fine job sorting through all the issues we’ve been reporting. But somewhere along the way, many of our concerns aren’t getting translated into code fixes, due to communications issues between the different teams or whatever.

I understand that you (or anyone else in the whole MSFS team) can only share so much information. And I appreciate you acknowledging our posts.

I think my last paragraph in my last post is probably the key takeaway with what I was trying to convey and the main source of frustration the community have outside of the actual growing bug list. We don’t get a ton of substantial communication, but it’s the disconnect between what’s communicated (the expectations are are set by the heads of the team) and what actually gets delivered that drives people nuts. High expectations are set, but when the time comes, the road map wasn’t even followed and they decided to go in a completely different direction instead. Hence the huge disappointment in the community.

Like you pointed out later, this community is very passionate about this sim. I can be very critical (and I’m pretty sure my name is likely used as a curse word across both MS and Asobo offices lol), as I look at it through the lens of both a user and a software dev for nearly 30 years. But be assured it’s very akin to a parent being hard on their kids so that they can excel and achieve greater things.

I love this sim, and I give a lot to this community with the free products I deliver for end users (Air Manager instruments). It’s just hard to be enthusiastic at times when for every step forward, there seems to be multiple steps backwards. And as you can easily tell with my user stats, I’m deeply embedded in this community and have a good feel of the pulse of things. I’m not the only one who feels this way.

But thank you for replying and addressing some of our concerns.

I can wait if it means JustFlight coming to console versions Marketplace

“The team” in this case refers to everyone who is actively working on MSFS at both Microsoft and Asobo. There are a relatively small number of people who are in public-facing roles like Jorg (head of Microsoft Flight Simulator), Sebastian (CEO of Asobo), Martial (Executive Producer), and the Community team (me, @Jummivana, @iinKWest, our boss @Skeedorr, and our colleague from Asobo @OlieTsubasa443) who you will most often see on this forum and our other channels like Discord, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and Twitch. But there are also nearly 200 people who work quietly on this project “behind the scenes” in roles such as production, design, development/coding, licensing, QA, audio engineering, Marketplace, and much more.

We (the Community team) are responsible for reading player feedback (from all channels) and sharing it with everyone else on the MSFS team. In our recurring MSFS all-hands team meetings (chaired by Jorg), one of the standing agenda items that is always discussed is sharing concerns, wishlist items, and other feedback from the player community. This is treated VERY seriously.

Although the devs try to be as responsive as they can, the nature of software development is that they can’t always react to player feedback as quickly as some of you would like. It’s also an unfortunate reality that many bugs that are perceived as “small or easy” fixes are often anything but. :frowning:

7 Likes

Thanks very much for that. I wasn’t sure if Skeedorr was just referring to “the Community team” or the entire MSFS team as a whole. Your post helped clear that up for me, and some other details as well. Thanks again and keep up the great work :+1:

Not sure if this one just happens to be missed and not pushed toward developers, but I feel the users/customers deserve a definitive answer since it was listed as an SU9 release item.
It was a very vague item listed with no further explanation by devs. Some clarification with this one specifically would be great. As users are starting to feel like it was just meaningless patch note filler fluff.


https://www.avsim.com/forums/topic/618092-su9-distance-between-external-camera-and-plane-how/

I can look into this further, but I believe this patch note referred to a change specifically for developers of modded planes to give them more control over custom camera settings for their addon aircraft. It wasn’t a new option intended for use by regular sim pilots.

2 Likes

Thank you!

Sorry I tried to use the search function to see if this was already answered, but can someone confirm if WASM for xbox is still planned for SU10?

Defiantly looking likely that it still coming in SU10. It is in the latest development update on there that was posted yesterday.

June 9th, 2022 Development Update - Microsoft Flight Simulator

You know after reading all the posts above I’m glad I have Aero Fly SIM as my back up. FS4 is coming out this month (just announced on STEAM) and I plan to have that too. Reading these posts is pushing me to stay with Aero Fly and abandon MSFS because I feel as many do, it will never be a finished product. To market something unfinished, and release it as a fix it as we go product is just…just…I have no words to describe it nor shall I descriptively. I’m a casual simmer and Aero Fly has enough eye candy to keep me coming back. No bugs, runs smoothly and is pre- optimized for you. To wait till August for the MSFS SU10 update and put up with the issues since SU9 is just…I don’t know. I’m loosing faith and confidence in MSFS now the more I read on these forums. Can you blame me or anybody else who is planning to abandon it given all its constant issues…? Many of us have spent loads of $$ on MSFS and we are not getting our $$'s worth and that’s wrong. It shouldn’t be this way.

If you’re looking for a finished product, which gets no more updates then you’re probably better off somewhere else. It would be financially impossible to build and then deliver a finished product to the level that MSFS is aiming at. It’s always going to be a constantly improved work in progress.

If you want a product where the basics are working well and then the extra bits are built on top well then that’s reasonable, MSFS isn’t there yet in a number of ways but clearly Asobo are trying to get there and certainly most of the users wish for this as soon as possible.

This sim is a massive technical achievement already and has too many rough spots, but as they say, Rome wasn’t built in a day.

I don’t consider the Aerofly series a full world sim, personally.
The reason it runs so smooth and “feels polished” is because the world is pretty bland and empty of detailed terrain/autogen etc etc outside of specific scenery areas. I’m glad there is a market for something lighter on performance and less visually/aerodynamically complex.
Comparing it to something as complex as MSFS is like apples to oranges IMO.

I feel it’s kinda naïve and unrealistic to expect something as huge and complex as MSFS to be a “finished product” within 2 years after release nor the next 5 years. Seems some customer’s should have conducted more research of Microsoft Flight Simulator Serie’s past and present development pace and structure. I would have bluntly informed a potential inexperienced flight sim buyer expecting a Aerofly FS Series complete polished product feeling from MSFS otherwise. Some customers knew this would be a constantly updated roller coaster ride of optimization, polish, bug fixes and new features the next 5 years, but now it isn’t going at their preferred pace nor order and they are unhappy.
It’s always been a constant ongoing technical evolution that covers many aspects from different developers.

MS/Asobo In House Research & Development
Third Party Scenery Development Tech
Third Party Weather Development Tech
Third Party Aircraft Simulation Development Tech

For just two years in I would say the progress of this sim is moving along and meshing quite well in an overall evolution in all aspects listed above.

Agreed on all points and Yes it is a remarkable achievement and very well done all things considered, no argument here. But one is allowed to voice an opinion…correct…? After all that’s what these forums are for if I recall :thinking: I like Aero Fly for its simplicity, and eye candy isn’t overly important to me. It’s enough to get the job done and be visually appealing. Nothing wrong with having a back up SIM when MSFS craps out or acts up…no…? As I stated I haven’t abandoned it yet and only considering it if things don’t improve…not on my desired whims but as time progresses. I thoroughly researched MSFS before I purchased it so I was well informed. I had to give it a chance right…? Then again maybe I’ll just keep both SIM’s and switch back and forth when I desire to. Change is always good…no…?
What is it they say…hmm…oh ya…“variety is the spice of life”. :grinning:

Have a good break and maybe we will see you back again.